Simply the best GF pizza we've ever had anywhere! Yes it's a little pricey but it's NYC. Definitely worth stopping by. You will not be disappointed!!!
Ate the pizza here w my daughter. No reactions. Tested it w my Nima Sensor and it came back GF. One of the best gf pizzas I have had. Based on other reviews I would say to make sure you are always clear when you order. Authentic Italian/Naples style.
Montanara starita Not bad, I prefer more cheese on my Pizza. I ate 2 hours ago and am feeling fine.
Something goes wrong. It ridiculous to pay 70 dollars for a dinner and get contaminated in a place that tells that there are separated kitchens and prepared staff. My wife stays really bad now, and the symptoms are 100% like she enters in contact with gluten, this is doubtless. We asked for two pizzas, and one of the two arrived in a wood instead of in a plate. When we ask if the wood was used only for gluten-free pizzas the busboy tells us that wasn't, and he seems not knowledgeable about the cross contamination (he tell us that, if we want, he can move the pizza to a normal plate). We eat really paranoid, that's not absolutely fair in a person's birthday, and after that the start to feel very bad and we can do nothing more than going home. Now she feels horrible like she has bitten a bread. 70 dollars thrown in the garbage. The pizza dough was pretty good, but the ingredients were nothing special.
Amazing! I've had their regular pizza before I learned that I was gluten intolerant, so I have a great comparison to know that their GF pizza tastes almost exactly the same. Was ordering takeout with a friend and mentioned to the manager I needed a GF pizza, she immediately recommended her favorites and without asking made both our dessert and salad bread GF as well! I'm used to having to skip out on the other dishes and only eat what I specifically ordered as GF but I didn't have to worry about it. The dessert (essentially fried dough sticks with Nutella) was AMAZING and reminded me that I can, in fact, do this whole GF thing while still indulging my sweet tooth from time to time.
Awesome pizza the best I've had gluten free . Dedicated oven ! Fantastic !
very good gluten free pizza. the make it in a different kitchen so no fear of cross contamination. They have a seperate gluten free menu with lots of choices
Excellent pizza! Whole page of the menu devoted to gf pizza. Separate oven for baking too. My daughter loved it!!
Separate kitchen for gf pizzas. I've been so paranoid about cross contamination I haven't had pizza in two years and it was worth the wait.
Had an amazing gluten free pizza. Crust was doughy, not flat and cardboard like most gluten free pizzas are. Good selection of pizzas to choose from.
Fabulous pizza. GF made in a separate kitchen. Best GF crust I think I've had!
Vary ogernized good for anyone
While the gf pizza crust was good, the rest of our experience was full of disappointments. Be warned, this place has nothing but pizza and calzone, you can't customize your pie - only ordering from pricey specialty pies ...and they don't have Parmesan cheese. All of this information was delivered in non-apologetic style and we left after our meal I satisfied and $110 poorer for me and three boys. Also, my marguerite pizza was an overpriced cheese pizza with three tiny leaves of basil in the middle....not a very good marguerite in my opinion.
This is my favorite pizza restaurant in midtown. Have always had a good meal -no gluten concerns- and great service. Tables move quickly so don't let a wait scare you. It's worth it.
We all choose from the gluten free menu. The pizza was delicious! The gluten free bread was also delicious.
The best gluten free pizza crust ever
Put the phone down, and go right now. Order the GF Montanara Starita. :-)
Great Gluten-free pizza. Great service! I will be back for more.
Great gluten free pizza. The base really makes the pie.
Mediocre, at best, pizza. I would not revisit.
Wow!! Gf pizza crust is terrific, but the *fried* gf pizza crust (house special montanara starita) is indistinguishable from regular crust!!! Also, entire staff knows how to handle gf. When the busboy asked if we wanted our leftovers wrapped up, I said yes and started to ask for separate boxes, and the busboy (not our waiter, but the busboy!) said, yes, I know that one is gf. Terrific experience.
Best gluten free pizza!! You wouldn't even know the crust is gluten free. A little pricey but definitely worth it. Can't wait to go back!
Best pizza I have ever eaten! And it was Gluten Free! I had The Butcher which is 4 different types of meat. It was heaven ! Lovely place. A bit expensive but that's typical for NY standards. I paid 25 for my pizza.. Prices ranged from 17-26 I believe. It was worth EVERY penny.
Gluten free pizza was fabulous! Lots of choices and perfect crust. Also serve Greens Gluten Free beer! I highly recommend this place.
pizza was horrible
We are visiting New York City and were looking for a gluten free pizza place as my sister had already eaten gluten pizza. We ordered from this place and they were very knowledgable. When we received the pizza, the crust didn't even look like it was gluten free. It tastes just like regular crust even though it was gluten free. Best pizza I have ever had and highly recommend this place. Also, it is very good if you have celiac disease. I visited again this past weekend and went two days in a row. I was very satisfied and the pizzas were delicious once again. They have a whole swept are kitchen and oven just for the gf pizza!
Montanara Starita is so amazing you'll question if it's really gluten free! Service was quick and friendly. Quite a few gluten free options available.
Just arrived in NYC and used the app to find this fabulous place. Our entire family of 11 enjoyed their pizzas. Delicious, thank you so much!
Went there this past weekend with my family. Ordered two gf pies for my wife and I and one non gf for our kids. Kids loved it. My wife and I loved ours as well, especially the one with proccuito, mushrooms and truffle oil. Best gf pizza we have ever had. Everything was fresh. Extremely friendly and knowledgeable staff. We'll definitely be back next time we're in the city.
Enjoyed the GF pizza this past weekend. It was excellent and fresh. Service is outstanding.
Excellent Restaurant!!! They have delicious GF pizza made in a dedicated Gf oven. Some of their GF pizza options uses fried dough (very tasty) - they use a dedicated fryer for their GF dough. The pizza was among some of the best GF pizza I've ever had!
pizza buonissima e servizio molto professionale.. per un celiaco che vuole mangiare pizza è assolutamente da provare. very good pizza and very professional for gluten allergy is a recommended place.. thanks to them i had a wonderful pizza!!!
Fast great friendly service! Nice gluten free menu. The waiter was fantastic, very knowledgable and more than happy to help.
Looooved the slightly fried gluten free pizza it was amazing and it doesn't taste like gluten free can't wait to go back.
The first gluten free pizza base I've ever enjoyed.
Best gluten free pizza I have ever had! Everyone was knowledgeable and helpful!
Most amazing gluten free pizza you will ever have. I first ordered delivery, and had to come consult this website to see if my pizza was actually gluten free because I couldn't believe it. The crust is so fluffy and soft (not at all the hard/cardboard GF style you get used to). They have many options for gluten free as well, which is a huge plus!
Probably the best gf pizza I've had! The restaurant is small, crowded, noisy and the staff work really hard. It's a fun atmosphere but not slow and relaxed. They have a gf menu and a totally separate prep area for their gf pizzas. The restaurant is a bit off of Times Square and I only found it because of find me GFree. They don't take reservations. The gf pizza crust is made of soy, rice and potato flours. I highly recommend you check this place out. They generally offer fried dough with Nutella for dessert and one other option but they were sold out tonight.
Best GF pizza I've ever had! So happy to have found this treasure. I have Celiac and feel very safe here. The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable. Enjoy!
Did I just eat the best pizza ever? Possibly! I think the only way to be sure is to put this side by side with Pala and do a true taste test. Either way, this is by far the best GF pizza in midtown, possibly NYC and maybe the best in the world.
We started with the gluten free Montanarine (their lightly fried dough topped with their sauce). Incredible! For main course we enjoyed the Montanara Starita and Margherita. Equally incredible! We ended up ordering a Margherita with Salami as well. Best pizza we have ever had, even before going gluten free! Keste was our favorite before, but now it's Don Antonio!
Excellent GF authentic Italian pizza
the best gluten free pizza by far anywhere in the USA! I travel a lot and try different places and pizzas and this is the best it has a New York taste and texture ! it is awesome!
INCREDIBLE authentic pizza! Honestly the best gf pizza I've had in my years of being gluten free. If you're in the area you must try it! I also had the gf fried dough with Nutella - delicious
Margarita pizza was amazing!! If you have celiac disease this is the place for you!!
Great food and staff. GF pizza is terrific. Cooked in separate area than non-gf items.
This place is truly authentic Italian pizza at its finest! If you are Celiac and in NYC, you MUST eat here. I had the GF prosciutto and arugula pizza with a glass of Pinot Grigio, and not only was it exquisitely delicious, it was super fast too!! We were in a hurry to be on time for the Rockettes. I can't wait to come back to NYC and eat at this place again!! Do yourself a favor and eat here!!!
Truly an amazing experience for a celiac in New York craving pizza! To Die For
I'm am not gluten free but my girlfriend is and this is one of the best pizza I have had. So if you have a craving for pizza this is where you need to go
best pizza i've ever had. let's get one of these to boston
Great GF pizza! Manager was very accommodating and sweet too.Would definitely go back!
Great food! Awesome gluten free menu.
Fantastic GF selection and great tasting food. Staff very aware of GF needs with top notch service. The owner even payed us a visit to tell us about the GF pizza dough. And the pizza is unbelievable. Impossible to know that it's even GF. Best I've had since Chiro's Restaurant in Florence, Italy.
These reviews are all true. Great pizza. They make it super fast too.
Amazing GF pizza. Actually, amazing pizza in general (GF or not.)
Best gf pizza I have had in my five years of being gf.
The Ortolana GF pizza was amazing! My non-GF family was also impressed; the service was attentive and charming... but it was super LOUD! But I would still go back - some of the very best pizza I've had, GF or regular!
Had fantastic GF pizza last night! Soft, chewy and delicious from a wood-burning oven with wonderful service as well.
Great service and delicious gluten free pizza! Drinks were also amazing!! Would definitely go again.
soft. chewy. just straight up DELIGHTFUL gluten free crust! I had the margherita pizza. The ingredients were fresh and traditional. By far the best GF pizza I've ever had. It's safe to say I'll dream of this pizza. The only reason I gave this place 4/5 stars is because our server forgot to put in our order. HOWEVER, they fixed the problem promptly. They brought us a complimentary salad to tide us over until our pizza came and then brought a complimentary (gluten friendly!) desert at the end.
Excellent Pizza! The best in NYC. Friendly staff, good service, & a big selection of Pizzas. A must for Celiacs :-)
Very good pizza-actually fluffy instead of super crispy like others I've had. A couple different toppings make it even better. Never gotten sick and I get their delivery all the time. It's also very fast delivery.
11:30 am - 11:00 pm
11:30 am - 11:00 pm
11:30 am - 11:00 pm
11:30 am - 11:00 pm
11:30 am - 11:30 pm
11:30 am - 11:30 pm
11:30 am - 10:30 pm