Very confused by the other posts. We live nearby and have spoken with them at length. We were told only vanilla and vanilla chip is gluten-free because everything else is made from the same batch and the next flavor they do is cookie dough. Not many options.
They make their own ice cream and the staff is very knowledgeable about the ingredients. I had the Peanut Butter Cup Fantasy and when I said I had Celiacs they washed the scoop and opened a new pot of ice cream for me!!