Gluten-Free at Bagel to Sandwich

Bagel to Sandwich

29 ratings
$$ • Bagel Shop
Reported to have a gluten-free menu
Popular gluten-free menu items: Bagels, Sandwiches, Bread/Buns
Safety Rating
23 ratings

As rated by the community

Most Recent Reviews


1 month ago

The most fantastic gf bagel ever!!!

Safety
Taste
Variety
Symptomatic Celiac
2 months ago

Had a good experience here. Avocado toast on plain GF bagel. Not much seating though. Recommend ordering ahead online.

Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Bagels
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Gluten Intolerant
4 months ago

Very good gf bagels with many flavors of cream cheese.

Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Bagels, Sandwiches

Important

This establishment is NOT a dedicated gluten-free facility and may not be safe for those with celiac disease. Please contact the establishment directly to inquire about safety precautions.
Information contained in this listing is based on reports by the community. Please verify all information directly with the establishment.

Reported safety features

Other

Collections
In 4 Public Collections

Photos


GF Healthy bagel with egg white omelette, Swiss cheese, avocado and turkey ham.
Gluten-Free at Bagel to Sandwich
Gluten-Free at Bagel to Sandwich
Smoked salmon with gf plain bagel
Bagel to Sandwich gluten-free menu
Gluten-Free at Bagel to Sandwich
Add a photo View all photos

More Reviews


Symptomatic Celiac
4 months ago

It was nice to have a gluten-free bagel and cream cheese, however they do not have a dedicated gf toaster, so I had to take the frozen gf bagel away with me to thaw and then eat it untoasted at my hotel room.

Safety
Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Bagels
Celiac
4 months ago

Have to be reminded twice to avoid cross contamination

Safety
Celiac
4 months ago

Amazing. Got a Spicy Italian Sandwich on a GF Plain …. heaven

Safety
Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Bagels, Sandwiches
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Celiac
4 months ago

The gf bagels were so good. I tried all three types and each one was soft and chewy. My non gluten free husband loved them and the cream cheese varieties we tried were all amazing.

Safety
Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Bagels
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Separate gluten-free menu
Gluten Intolerant
4 months ago

I am gluten intolerant and lactose intolerant. I ordered the sesame gluten free bagel of which there are three GF choices. The rest of the bagels are made with gluten at this facility and they have about 50 different varieties for those that can eat gluten. They show bagels with all kinds of fillings which makes it easier to pick. They also have 20 different flavours of cream cheese to go on the bagels. My GF sesame bagel was soft, moist and chewy, the way a bagel should be! Mine was an egg sandwich with pastrami which tasted wonderful! It was huge and filling so I saved the other 1/2 for another day:)

Safety
Taste
Variety
Other
  • — Takeout
Celiac
5 months ago

was a little nervous to go here since it seems like there may not be the best cross contamination procedures (and i don’t know my sensitivity level) but i’m happy to say i didn’t get any adverse symptoms afterwards

it’s a good bagel with a shit ton of cream cheese (i feel like i got my own container’s worth) and i added some eggs. but because there was so much cream cheese, i couldn’t really finish bc it turned into a mess so fast (just a warning if that’s not your thing!)

it’s a cute place and also has pretty good coffee. obviously there was more non-gf options so if you’re going with a group, they’ll have a lot to choose from

Safety
Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Bread/Buns, Bagels
5 months ago

Phenomenal!! Absolutely the best GF bagel that I have had…ever. Only wish I had discovered BTS earlier. The texture and taste of the everything bagel was perfect. The coffee was also excellent.

Do yourself a favor and try this place. I’m so glad I found it and will make it a priority to visit again next time I’m in the city.

Safety
Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Bagels
Hashimoto's
6 months ago

Excellent GF sesame bagel toasted egg sandwich! I’m not Celiac, but have a gluten sensitivity and my daughter has Hashimotos. We both enjoyed our breakfast. I can see though how celiac may struggle with cross contamination.

They had 3 different types of GF bagels.

[edit] We went back twice as the bagels were so good. Definitely ask for the GF bagel to be toasted as it’s much better.

Safety
Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Bagels
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
GF Healthy bagel with egg white omelette, Swiss cheese, avocado and turkey ham.
Hashimoto's
7 months ago

Bagel was decent. They use premade bagels (Sunshine sometbing??) . It uses gf wheat starch.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — No gluten-free information on the menu
Gluten Intolerant
7 months ago

These were the best gluten free bagels I’ve ever had. Their bagel sandwiches were awesome! We went there 3 times because my daughter in law said the coffee was amazing. ( I don’t drink coffee) staff was friendly and helpful. Would definitely go again when in NY!

Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Bagels, Sandwiches
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Other
  • — Good for alcohol-free
7 months ago

Terrible service. They only had the GF bagel but non of the cream cheese were GF except the regular one. When we asked if they could scoop the cream cheese from a new one or a side that had not been touched, they looked at us as if we had three heads and said no.

Symptomatic Celiac
7 months ago

Three different bagel options, I didn’t see if the have a designated gluten free toaster

Safety
Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Bagels
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Celiac
8 months ago

Fluffy bagels with lots of cream cheese in each bite. Happy to have had my first GF NYC bagel here!

Safety
Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Bagels
Gluten-Free at Bagel to Sandwich
Celiac
8 months ago

So yummy! Had trouble finding a gluten free bagel place until stumbled across this gem. Had gluten free bagels that were so delicious. Would definitely recommend

Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Bagels
Gluten-Free at Bagel to Sandwich
10 months ago

The GF bagel sandwiches are so good. I came here last summer and I’ve been thinking about going back ever since. I’m back in the city and this is my first stop for a delicious and filling breakfast. I’m gluten sensitive so it works for me but I’m sure there’s cross contamination. The have vegan cream cheese too.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Separate gluten-free menu
Gluten Intolerant
1 year ago

Tasty gluten free bagels

Taste
Variety
Symptomatic Celiac
1 year ago

CANNOT AVOID CROSS CONTAMINATION WITH GLUTEN. If you are severely sensitive like me then do not go here. The GF bagels are frozen and MUST pass through the conveyor oven with all other bagels. Staff was unwilling to wrap bagel in foil to safely pass thru conveyor oven or wipe down griddle to warm up that way.

Safety
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — No gluten-free information on the menu
Safety
  • — No dedicated fryer
Celiac
1 year ago

Very good GF bagel. Staff was wonderful.

Safety
Taste
Celiac
1 year ago

Gluten free bagels frozen, and toasted in the same toaster as all the other bagels. Took a long walk to get here, so disappointed.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — No gluten-free information on the menu
Symptomatic Celiac
1 year ago

Nice option for breakfast sandwich with tasty GF bagels. Affordable for NYC.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Separate gluten-free menu
Celiac
1 year ago

Frozen bagel, not store made. Not suitable for sensitive and celiac. Had to ask for use of separate knife.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Safety
  • — No dedicated fryer
Gluten Intolerant
1 year ago

Amazing choices highly recommend! Never been able to eat a bagel from a shop in years

Safety
Taste
Variety
Symptomatic Celiac
1 year ago

Amazing food service was quick and workers were very pleasant. Would go here again

Safety
Taste
Variety
Celiac
1 year ago

So fantastic! I would eat here every week if I lived nearby. So friendly, knew exactly what to do. The owner is excited about coming up with new gluten free options. Staff was so nice! Gave my sister a cookie on the house (she's not gf lol he offered me one too!)

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Safety
  • — Knowledgeable staff
  • — Staff accommodates
  • — Food flagged
Other
  • — Outdoor seating
  • — Breakfast/Brunch
  • — Lunch
  • — Takeout
Smoked salmon with gf plain bagel
Hashimoto's
1 year ago

Fantastic shop! The owner is super nice and there were several choices of gluten free bagels and bread. They also have vegan cream cheese available.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
2 years ago

This new bagel shop has GF bread which is a savior on mornings I couldn’t eat at home but was a good breakfast. I got a BEC on GF bread and it was great. They also gave me coffee on the house.

Safety
Taste
Variety

More Info