Cosimos Brick Oven of Wallkill
$$ • Restaurant
Most Recent Reviews
Got sick after having gluten free pasta. Do not recommend eating here if you have celiac or severe allergies.
Ate there twice; got sick both times. Servers very nonchalant about gluten allergy--both told me if they tell the chef gluten free pasta, he's careful. Nope! The food is always great here, but expensive.
Had a very nice white broccoli pizza with added sausage. As always, I asked for well done crust. Very nice. My wife enjoyed her shrimp with potatoes. Very nice patio area. I did not get sick. I'll be back!
Photos
More Reviews
Ordered a gf pasta dish. Ended up being regular pasta. Won’t be going back there anymore. Waitress was so nonchalant about the mistake.
Never had a problem with Cosimo’s. Staff is friendly and accommodating. Food is delicious.
Explained to staff about my celiac disease and how sensitive I am ahead of time. Unfortunately I was so sick within 2 hours of consumption. I only ate tossed salad with polenta and grilled chicken. I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone who has gluten sensitivity.
They served me gluten free pasta with a roux based sauce. I almost vomited in their bathroom. I had stopped going here years ago and now I remember why. The reviews from the "normies" in my group weren't much better. I don't like to trash a restaurant, but I really don't like this place. They are totally phoning it in.
Food is great, I've had the gf pasta, gf pizza, and salads with no reaction.
