Goodfellow's Italian Chop House

3.0 stars 3.0 out of 5 8 ratings
$$$Pizza, Bread/Buns, Cider + 4 more
40% of 5 votes say it's Celiac friendly

1359 Hoban Street, Mackinac Island, MI 49757 Directions

(906) 847-0260
  • User profile picture thumbnail
    1 ratingSeptember 18, 2017

    When I called was told they could not guarantee there would be no cross contamination. Said no restaurants on island would guarantee safety. She was pretty accurate on that one. Mackinaw Island is not celiac safe, unless you eat at the 2 big hotel spots.

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    1 ratingJune 28, 2015

    My 1 star is only toward "Gluten Free". If you have celiacs I don't suggest you eat there! I do and I we t here becz reviews made it sound safe however, I had a captures salad which is Mozzarella, tomatoes and basil and I had a not so fun reaction. I was also told that their kitchen does not have a designated "gluten free" area. If fact he said the gluten free pizza is made on the same table as the regular pizzas so if this is just a diet for you... Go ahead a try it. Their food good. But if you have celiacs... Stay clear! Other than that my family enjoyed there pizza but only because we told the waiter "very light cheese." We saw a family next to us leave half their pizza there because it was so cheesy, it was gross! Ours was perfect and tasty so ask for light cheese! Our waiter was awesome! He was very friendly, attentive, funny and helpful! I wish I could remember his name to give him a shout out because he really was great!

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    4 ratingJune 12, 2015

    Very good! A bit pricey, but everything is on the island. Server was aware of what menu items could be made GF. They have GF pizza as well as GF hamburger buns. I had the Salmon with a buttery dill sauce, mashed red potatoes and steamed carrots and green beans. All very tasty!

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    3 ratingAugust 28, 2014

    My daughter had a hamburger which she enjoyed very much, but we were told the fries were not GF, nor did they have chips. Luckily, we had some with us that they allowed us to eat.

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    5 ratingAugust 26, 2014

    Good selection of GF items. I ordered a mushroom and swiss burger on GF bun. The fries were also GF. The burger was good. The bun was a typical GF bun, nothing special, but decent. My family that is not GF also enjoyed their meals. The waitress was very knowledgeable and helpful. We will go back next time we're on the island.

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    4 ratingAugust 01, 2013

    Had the flat bread gluten free pizza which was good but not excellent. Anything else gluten free is either sandwiches or hoagies on a gluten free bun. Didn't have those

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    3 ratingJuly 28, 2013

    Got the GF flatbread pizza, pretty good. A couple other options were listed on the menu as GF which is always a bonus.

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    4 ratingMay 21, 2013

    have a good selection of GF options. did not try the buns or pizza.

Gluten-Free Features

  • Beer
  • Bread/Buns
  • Cider
  • Pizza


  • Italian
  • Lunch
  • Restaurant
8 am - 10 pm
8 am - 10 pm
8 am - 10 pm
8 am - 10 pm
8 am - 11 pm
8 am - 11 pm
8 am - 9 pm

Be the first to add a photo!

map of Goodfellow's Italian Chop House

Nearby restaurants

Do you own a gluten-free friendly business?
Contact us to talk about your advertising options.