Key West Key Lime Pie Co

71 ratings
$ • Dessert Shop
84% of 13 votes say it's celiac friendly
511 Greene Street
Key West, FL 33040

Top Reviews


Overall Rating

Review


They offer gluten free key lime pie and freshly dipped chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick. The staff was nice and knowledgeable about gluten free. She did give me a heads up if you don't eat the gluten free pie it will start to melt in about 10 minutes. I ate the chocolate covered one right away and the slice the next day. It was good, but I liked the taste and balance of Kermits better. It is good though and great to have gf options to compare.

Safety


How confident are you that this establishment takes safety precautions against cross-contamination?

— Very

Quality & Quantity


Is there a gluten-free menu?

— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu

How much of the menu is available gluten-free?

— Some

How would you rate the taste and quality of the gluten-free food you tried?

— Good

Other


Other Characteristics
  • Good for takeout
  • Offers online ordering
Updated 6 months ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


I walked in and asked the woman behind the counter if she had any gluten free options. And she said no so I turned around and walked out!

Safety


How confident are you that this establishment takes safety precautions against cross-contamination?

— Not very

Quality & Quantity


Is there a gluten-free menu?

— No gluten-free information on the menu

How much of the menu is available gluten-free?

— Not Much

How would you rate the taste and quality of the gluten-free food you tried?

— Average

Updated 8 months ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


No gluten free options other than sorbet when I went

Updated 1 year ago read full review

This establishment is NOT a dedicated gluten-free facility and may not be safe for those with celiac disease. Please contact the establishment directly to inquire about safety precautions.

Gluten Free Features

  • Dessert
  • Pies

Categories

  • Online Ordering
  • Takeout

Photos


photo thumbnail
photo thumbnail
photo thumbnail
photo thumbnail
photo thumbnail
Gf key lime pie
Add a photo View all photos

More Reviews


Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Gf key lime pie and gf key lime pie on a stick dipped in chocolate. Both were delicious.

Updated 1 year ago read full review

Not celiac

Overall Rating

Review


GF pie available plus a chocolate covered one as well.

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 1 year ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


What a treat...a slice of pie in Key West! I bought the gf key lime pie slice and my husband had the gf chocolate covered one. The chocolate covered one is frozen and comes in a wrapper that says “gluten free” on it. However, before I bought my slice of gf pie, I asked if they cut it with a separate knife and if they are careful with handling it so that there isn’t any cross contact. The employee told me that the gf pies are made in a separate area and they use dishes and knives that are dedicated to the gluten free pies. she said they are very careful.

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 1 year ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Gluten free key lime pie by the slice or whole pie. Can also get a slice dipped in chocolate. Delicious!

Updated 1 year ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Yum! This is the best gf key lime pie. It’s light and airy with a gf graham cracker crust. They also have chocolate dipped pie slices. Yum!

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 1 year ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Nice place with very tasty GF Key lime pie

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 1 year ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


My second choice in Key West although this was still very good. A lighter, more whipped option than Kermit’s denser filling. I found this less lime intense and tartness is my preference. Three dedicated GF options which was more than Kermit’s.

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 1 year ago read full review

Not celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Delicious GF key lime pie! Just the right combo of sweet/tartness. My husband is gluten intolerant and had no issues afterwards. Even returned the next day for another slice!

Updated 1 year ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Delicious! More tart than Kermit’s. Overall, very good.

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 1 year ago read full review

Overall Rating

Review


Husband (not celiac) and I (celiac) stopped in here for this classic great while in Key West. I haven’t had a slice since my diagnosis and it used to be a favorite dessert. The staff claimed the slice they would be able to sell me was too small to charge me, so they gave it to me on the house. I expected a tiny sliver! However, mine was only slightly smaller (barley discernible unless compared side to side)! Delicious!!!!

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 1 year ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


I have never had key lime pie in my life! My husband was annoyingly insisting I try it so we finally made the trip to this shop. I even made him only buy the gluten free slice because I was so sure I wouldn’t like it! After one bite I knew I made a huge mistake! The next day I went back and got the chocolate covered slice, AMAZING! The label does indicate its made in a shared facility, but I’m a pretty sensitive celiac and had no issues. They were sure to use separate utensils and even prepared it at a separate station.

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 1 year ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


If you’re a celiac don’t go here. The ingredient lists that it was made in a factory that also makes wheat products— the pie is nice t made here— be aware

Celiac friendly?

No

Updated 2 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Super yummy creamy key lime pie and gf graham cracker crust.

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 2 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


I found this particular "best key lime pie in Key West" using the app. I don't often get key lime pie any longer, but theirs is amazing. If you have Celiac's disease, you can eat this little green pie with confidence. Love it!

Updated 2 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


My husband is a key lime pie person. We tried pie here, Kermit’s, and the “original” key lime pie. He declared the lie here the best. That said, I am not a big fan of key lime pie; but in the spirit of adventure, I tried the GF pie here and at Kermit’s; not the “original” key lime pie because they do not have a GF offering. I, too, thought the pie here was far superior.

Updated 2 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Be careful.. gf is not celiac friendly .. it says processed on equipment that processes wheat!

Updated 2 years ago read full review

Not celiac

Overall Rating

Review


To die for key lime pie! THE BEST! So thankful they have GF!! Made my trip!;) Thank you, thank you!!

Updated 3 years ago read full review

Not celiac

Overall Rating

Review


I got the chocolate covered pie on a stick. My wife got the pie. Both were delicious and I had no reaction. I did see the server pick up what appeared to be the universal slicer to cut into th newly opened gluten free pie. I didn't eat any of my wife's pie that day (we went multiple days). I can't say for certain that there was cross contamination but better safe than sorry. Just a tip to keep an eye out when you're there and to ask questions. (I wasn't in the mood to ask...)

Updated 3 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


The GF pie was absolutely delicious. Careful staff. No cross contamination.

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 3 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Great gluten free key lime pie. Gluten free key lime slice on a stick was good as well and separately packaged and labeled GF.

Updated 3 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Amazing pie and friendly service. Tried lots of pie throughout our trip to Key West and this was definitely the favorite. Highly recommend for an afternoon treat!

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 3 years ago read full review

Not celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Finally gluten-free Key Lime Pie!!!!!

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 3 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


The pie was very good! Was so excited to find a good gluten free option.

Updated 3 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Yuuuuuummmmmmmmmm!!!!! Both the pie and the chocolate dipped pie were delicious!

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 3 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Gf Original slice key lime pie Omg. RUN here. Don't walk. RUN! so good!!!!! Yikes. Glad I don't live here. It would be a daily treat. 😬

Updated 3 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Melt in your mouth. So good!

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 4 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Delicious GF key like pie. Did not get sick. Nice staff. Great location.

Updated 4 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


I have had the Key Lime GF pie it is amazing and the do have by the slice or whole pie.

Updated 4 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


they no longer have gf pie and are not friendly in any way. the man working the counter was very terse when explaining the store lost lots of money from having to throw out expired gf pie.

Updated 4 years ago read full review

Overall Rating

Review


They have no more GF pie :(

Updated 4 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


They had A LOT of gluten free options. I've never had key lime pie and the gluten free version was amazing! They were careful about putting on gloves to cut the pie and being sure the whipped cream was fresh. I highly recommend.

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 4 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


I had the chocolate dipped key lime pie and it was to die for! I felt "normal" eating a dessert alongside my boyfriend who had the same (non GF) version!

Updated 4 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


They had gluten free options on the normal menu which is one of my favorite things! Came here a couple different times and didn't get sick once! Got the frozen chocolate dipped key lime pie on a stick! Such a great treat!

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 4 years ago read full review

Overall Rating

Review


The gentleman there asked if I had a gluten allergy and then explained he would have to handle my food separately in another area. The pie was fabulous but the dark chocolate dipped key lime pie was decadent. So much so that we came back a second time!

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 5 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Really enjoyed my pie! Both people working that night were knowledgeable about the gluten free version of their pie which I give them props for. The one thing that concerned me was that she used the same whipped cream piping bag for both versions of pie, which immediately made me nervous. Also, it didn't sound like they made the gluten free version in a separate facility.

Updated 5 years ago read full review

Not celiac

Overall Rating

Review


First time I've ever been able to eat key lime pie since being gluten free!!! I can't tell you how fun it was to be able to share the experience with my husband, who doesn't have to eat gf. I got the pie dipped in chocolate and frozen.. And it came in its own individual wrapper so I knew it didn't touch anything else. Not only were they great about avoiding cross-contamination, but it was delicious!! Highly recommend

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 5 years ago read full review

Not celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Great gf key lime pie

Updated 5 years ago read full review

Overall Rating

Review


Yay! Dedicated equipment, great desserts! Several GF options so that's our dessert spot for our entire stay. Coffee too.

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 5 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


absolutely amazing. they took so much care to cut my pie using gf utensils. the pie was fantastic! first time eating key lime Pie!went 2x. love it

Updated 5 years ago read full review

Overall Rating

Review


Celaic friendly! So accepting! Off the charts if you have a serious sweet tooth

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 5 years ago read full review

Overall Rating

Review


Amazing GF options including key lime pie with crust!

Updated 5 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Excellent get the gluten free key lime pie

Updated 5 years ago read full review

Not celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Delicious key lime pie!!

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 5 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


Great key lime pie! Crust was perfect!

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 5 years ago read full review

Not celiac

Overall Rating

Review


By far the best GF key lime pie in Key West. I had a slice (which they quite literally slice for you when you order it), every single night of our trip. The one night I deviated (Kermits), I was sorry I had. Key Lime Pie Co's didn't have the bitter aftertaste that many key lime pie's do and the GF version had a proper graham cracker crust on it, which was great :-) its so refreshing to eat something and instead of saying "well its good for being gluten free" so just say "man, this is SO good". Don't miss it!!!

Celiac friendly?

Yes

Updated 6 years ago read full review

Overall Rating

Review


Lots of gluten free options and delicious shilled key lime pie. Amazing and would definitely go there again.

Updated 6 years ago read full review

Celiac

Overall Rating

Review


I'd never gotten to try key lime pie before but this place had incredible pie! the original or the toasted pineapple coconut is great! I'm a very sensitive celiac and I had no issues with the 5 visits I made during my trip!

Updated 6 years ago read full review

More Info