Mellow Mushroom

Believe our food was cross contaminated, would not go back again.

Gluten free crust tastes great and is nice and crisp. Many toppings to choose from.

Our family's favorite gf pizza!!! Great staff. Separate prep area & pizza oven.

I give it 2 stars because they have a gf menu AND I've never gotten sick from eating there. But the pizza isn't good. It's better if you ask them for extra cooked. Otherwise it's like eating very expensive soggy cardboard. There's better gf pizza out there. Somewhere.

This is one of my LEAST favorite GF pizzas in Columbus and very overpriced!

Worst gf pizza ever! Very soggy crust and the staff didn't care. They just said "that's the way it is."

Pizza was good. Our server had no clue about which salad dressings were gluten-free. We believe my husband ingested gluten from the salad dressing.

Pizza was amazing!

Love they are an option but their gf pizza is my least favorite in town. I find it soggy and lacking cravability. There prices are high too.

I don't like the gf pizza crust but they have a ton of options. Baked wings, an amazing spinach salad with bacon and 3 types of gf beers. The staff is informed and willing to go the extra mile. Love this place.

great gluten-free pizza!!!

Staff is knowledgable. Pizza is pretty good. Items well marked. Eaten here several times and never get sick (that’s key!)

Love the music, live band on a Wednesday afternoon in the spring and a Monday afternoon in the fall. Had a GF BBQ chicken pizza this time, staff was friendly and listened, it was about average for GF pizza and I didn't get sick, I would go back.

I have been here probably 5 times and have never gotten sick! They are super careful and knowledgeable. Always a delicious and safe choice! the pizza is great

I like that they specify the GF pizzas are made in a separate area, gloves and aprons are changed. I got the veg out pizza. The crust was pretty good, but it was not crispy in the middle. I'd go again, but I'd really probably prefer making my own GF pizza at home.

Limited GF selection. Stressed I have an allergy and I needed GF several times. Was brought non-GF pizza and had to flag someone else down to confirm it was not in fact GF.

Highest on web search but not gf friendly.. very few options for gf.

I went to this location yesterday and was very happy with my service and my food. I alerted my server and spoke to the manager on duty whose name was Collin about my celiacs and how sensetive I am to gluten. They took great care of my pizza. I will be going back for sure and would highly recommend this location.

Great place and great pizza! Three of us with Celiac and absolutely no issues. The food does take longer to come out but, that is because they have one person doing the gluten free prep and cooking so there is no chance of contamination. The menu is clearly marked and I have zero complaints. We will definitely be back.

This place went above and beyond to make our meal safe for our son with celiac disease. When they ran out of gluten free pizza dough, they went to another restaurant who uses the same gf dough and bought some just to make our pizza. This general manager went above and beyond to make sure that we got a certified gluten free meal. My son did not get sick and we would go back again in a heartbeat.

Very knowledgeable staff and they have a separate process for gluten free pizza. Pizza was delicious.

Lots of gf and df options and delicious pizza! Be sure to let them know that you’re celiac!

Ordered a gluten free pizza and was very sick. Would not advise anyone with celiac to eat here.

The food was good. I didn’t get sick. I had a salad and a kosmic something pizza. They were both tasty!! (I rated this on food and celiac... however everything was dirty. The menus were gross. The table was dirty. My wine came with food particles on the glass. The rolled silverware had dried food on it. The floor was dirty.)

Delicious GF pizza (I bit too crispy though) and spinach salad

Had no problem ordering a gluten free pizza and had zero reactions

Good gluten free pizza, menu marked out what toppings were gluten free.

One of my favorite restaurants! It’s a little pricey, but they always take our allergies extremely seriously (Dairy and gluten) The pizza itself is phenomenal!! The dairy free cheese is to die for, and you don’t have to worry about getting contaminated.

Ate here twice this week. Pizza and baked wings. Very sensitive but no issues. Also delivery by door dash a plus

Not the best GF pizza I’ve ever had but I’m still glad they have it available! I also don’t eat cheese and the Veg Out GF pizza with no cheese was decent. Our server was knowledgeable about ingredients.

Great place to get a safe quick meal. Wings and pizza gluten free and staff is very knowledgable about celiac.

have dedicated area for GF! and even DF cheese, follow your heart is the good kind. Staff super knowledge and so happy to have pizza!!

I had a delicious dairy free and gluten free pizza and did not get sick. Also had New planet Gluten Free beer. Not gluten removed. Brewed gluten free. I was impressed. Edit to add: they had excellent allergy protocols listed on the back of their menu. Only certain toppings are handled under allergy protocols so read the menu carefully.

Fantastic gluten free crust! Best I've tasted. Menu is well-marked on which toppings are safe. Fun restaurant!

Delicious food and superb service! They were very accommodating when we wanted to watch a baseball game that wasn’t on any of the dozens of tvs in the establishment. Great place to watch the game!

I’ve had the gf pizza twice, once in the restaurant everything was great and then once delivered, within 30 minutes of eating it I was terribly ill. Not sure what happened it...was the same pizza with same toppings as last time. Thinking there was some cross contamination this time. Super disappointed.

Best gluten free pizza in town. Better than Brixx for sure.

Good tasty pizza. Hard to find a good pizza place with a separate cooking process for GF. They do charge extra for GF crust and my toppings were a bit sparce for the price I paid. But overall good, and was safe!

Excellent gf pizza! I love all the locations of Mellow Mushroom that I’ve visited, always good and I never have issues with them at all!

I have ordered the gluten free pizza from here and the salads. I felt fine and was so happy to have pizza! It was pretty good

We didn't plan on eating here, but the day got rearranged so we decided to get pizza knowing it was a safe option and there are very little on the parkway. Wish I would have read the reviews. It's me and my kids and they seat us in the bar. There are tons of seats open everywhere else in the restaurant and the bar is empty. Kinda odd. First thing we notice is that every item (reg.pizza, GF pizza and salads) are all $5 more than where we live in Knoxville. But we're there and we're hungry. My daughter and I split a Greek salad and a GF pizza. Salad was good but dressing is very thick. GF crust was undercooked and didn't hold toppings on. Toppings were tasty and better quality than crust. My son ate a traditional crust and said the same, that toppings were good but crust not very flavorful. Interesting since it's not GF but same issue. All in all, it was a decent lunch but awfully expensive.

Excellent gluten free pizza. Love that they offer vegan cheese.

Separate prep space and separate oven! Nima tested GF! Service wise, you may have to wait though :)

Delicious GF free pizza. Super fast service.

They have GF options on a regular menu and showed me the certified GF options. They have a separate work station for GF pizzas. The crust was good.

This was a great experience. We ordered the GF pizza for my 6yo twins with Celiac and they liked it. They have a separate prep area and oven for GF. We watched the cook switch aprons and gloves before fixing their pizza.

I have celiac disease and get sick at the smallest amount of gluten. With that being said, the pizza here is really good! I'll be coming back in the future. :)

Limited GF selections, but staff was informed. My pizza was undercooked and the crust was a bit gummy. A bit pricey.

They have a separate station for preparing GF pizzas. Pizzas are tasty!

We enjoyed this place so much we went twice. Both times I had the House Special gluten free pizza. It was SO good! I wish we had one near us!

(Review from a local) Best celiac experience we’ve had at a restaurant ever! They are as good as some Disney restaurants when it comes to allergies!! They have a separate prep space and allergy oven. They use corn masa to roll their regular pizzas instead of flour so airborne gluten isnt too much of an issue. We were able to speak directly with the manager and he made the pizzas himself to ensure no cross contamination and myself and my celiac son felt great after. Also, they carry glutenberg beers for those that like to enjoy a certified gluten free beer with their pizza.

Waiter was very good about letting us know which food was "no gluten ingredients" and which were properly gluten free. Annoyingly GF on menu is not the marking for "free of any gluten". GF pizza was very good and would happily go back.

The pizza was sooo good and the staff was extremely knowledgeable on allergens. I ordered the gluten free pizza with pesto and follow your heart vegan cheese since I have a milk allergy as well. The waitress came out a few minutes later and told me that the pesto had cheese in it so I was able to order something else. I had a great experience plus they have a Rubik’s cube sign on the wall so that is definitely worth checking out!

They clearly take gluten allergies very seriously because they shut down the line and clean it to cook the pizzas separately. They even keep certain ingredients in a separate fridge which is why certain GF ingredients are not labeled as such - because they’re in a fridge with non GF items. I thought that was pretty cool. The one drawback is the time you have to wait for your order, but not getting sick is worth it. Just be prepared to wait and if you’re eating with non GF people just go ahead and let them eat first.

Wait and kitchen staff knowledgeable- cider and GF Mighty Meaty pizza

menu is confusing, no GF appetizers, first thing they try to do is give you booze, been there twice with no GF dough available. Could not get order right, after waitress explained menu and we made choices we still got wrong pizzas.

We were told the toppings couldn’t be guaranteed to be gluten free when we requested pineapple. They didn’t offer to pull from the bottom or anything that we’ve been offered at other places.

Great gluten free pizza. So good.

Its expensive for a gluten free pizza...I have Celiac and react strongly when glutened. I never get a reaction, but be careful cause they use paper straws in their drinks and I don't know if they have gluten in them or not as the paste or body of the straw. They are kinda rude whenever asked questions. I just don't use the straws.

Love the gluten free crust at Mellow Mushroom. It’s always consistent and never disappoints. Had the House Special today with no reaction. (Anaphylactic to wheat )

We ordered for pick up. They did gluten free really well, and the pizza was pretty good. We had the mighty meat - toppings were delicious. The crust was a little soft, but that is unfortunately common with gluten free. Regardless, it was good and safe, and we'd eat there again.