Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Restaurant
$$$ • Pizza Restaurant
Most Recent Reviews
Service was amazing, Christina was our server and was amazing! The pizza was so light and fluffy. Really enjoyed it and a top of pizza ever for us. She said they usually have GF rolls but not that evening. So many GF options. Really wish we tried the rice balls or mozzarella sticks. We would definitely go back.
This was recommended as a great place for good Italian food with many GF OPTIONS. IT DID NOT DISAPPOINT!!! The gf penne a la vodka was amazing! The salad with house dressing also amazing and the offer gf rolls. Many gf options in the menu including pizzas and entrees. Some options online were not available in the restaurant. I recommended they update their website. I am looking forward to trying something else next time…. And there will be a next time in the near future.
Save your money. Pizza was like cardboard. Not made fresh in house. $16 for a personal GF pizza. So so disappointing
Photos
More Reviews
I have ordered from here several times. They have separate prep space, a separate oven, and a separate fryer. I have never gotten sick! Their gf pizza and gf chicken tenders are incredible.
I love the mozzarella sticks, the triangle shape makes them stay together more instead of just falling apart like other gf mozzarella sticks! The pizza is good but ask them to burn it a little! Lots of gluten free options and never gotten sick befroe!
I eat here a lot, server is fabulous. Lots of options
They have a separate oven for their gluten free pizzas! They make personal pizzas (could feed two with a salad though).
Unfortunately I was so let down this place... was looking forward to the gluten free mozzarella sticks (which are shaped like triangles, not squares, be careful because the employees there were not sure which was which). They were very crumbly! The bread crumbs kind of resembled pretzels. The gluten free pizza was not good! Nothing like NY pizza and the crust is the worst gluten free crust I have had. It resembled saltine crackers or like another review said matzah.
Tried to order online they never confirmed our order but charged us and then was told no gluten free pizza after waiting 20 mins when we asked for something else we were told 1 hour and 40 min wait. It’s Wednesday at 7:21... will never order again!!!! I am starving
Wonderful place to eat. They care to make a good meal for all. The food is like all Italian food... great!!
They have a lot of choices
I've been eating at Michael Anthony's for a long time they do have a great gluten free menu. I would have to disagree that everything is pre made. I have had their mozzarella sticks which are impossible to be store bought because I have never seen them cut in triangles or their fried calamari. Some people just don't know good food. A must try for all
Celiac friendly. they make nothing in house though, everything is bought pre- done and frozen.
This restaurant was awesome! Great God and the nicest Waters's ever. A small, quaint environment but ur family would eat here over a big chain any day! Tons of gluten free options and their cook's food is the best food we've eaten and we eat out every week! Definitely try it!
Huge Gluten Free sign out front lit up they have EVERYTHING GF and I mean everything even cannoli's!!! Great pizza and pasta doesnt taste GF at all!
This restaurant has AMAZING gluten-free options! Nearly the entire menu can be made gluten free, and it tastes fantastic! I love this restaurant so much that I'm having my wedding rehearsal here!
FAVORITE PLACE!!! I'm extremely sensitive Celiac (with numerous other food allergies) and this is my favorite and go-to place. Amazing food, staff is super friendly and accommodating. Love love love Michael Anthony's!
Horrible food. The pizza crust was thin and hard like matzoh. AND the food got me sick! I won't be going back.
First time I ordered a take out and had it delivered. I hate to say it but it was absolutely horrible. I ordered meatball parm with spaghetti, and got a least 3 quarter pounds of spaghetti and 2 meatballs. Not at all what I ordered number one. The spaghetti was white,and dry, hardly any sauce. The food just did not taste good, not Italian to me, as I am Italian and was raised on Italian food. The menu we looked at on the internet was also different priced than what the price turned out to be
The receipt you get does NOT tell you the prices. They also had the nerve to stick a hard heal end of "Italian" bread which was hard and dry. gross.
I am very annoyed and surprised since I paid a lot for this meal, (my sister ordered something too) and I also tipped the boy $7.00.. I feel like it was left over food, probably laying around for a while if just was not good, defiantly no Italian favor at all. I will not order or go there ever again, and If anyone asks me if I ate there and how I liked it I'm going to tell them my experience which was not good at all.
Many gluten-free choices to choose from ! My sons pizza was a bit soggy but I had the gluten-free buffalo chicken pie and it was AWESOME!! Wish I lived closer!
Happy to see so many gluten free menu choices. Actually had trouble deciding what to order, the Chicken marsala was tasty and salad was better than average. I definately want to try to try the baked clams next time, haven't seen them offered anywhere else.
Mike is more than accomodating being I have multiple food allergies as well as Celiacs. Just when I thought my food options were dwindling, he offed a wide variety of delicious solutions. I now buy several dinners, portion and freeze for quick meals during the week. I have eaten at his places for over 15 years(even prior to diagnosis) and the fantastic food and wonderful hospitality is unbeatable!
I had an excellent gluten free creep stuffed with vegetables draped with a bechemel sauce and the service was great can't wait for them to open their dinning room good luck will def be back all must try.won't be let down
We just had a great gluten free dinner!! Very delicous and lots of choices. Going to try the pizza next time. It's definitely worth a try.
