Nolan's on Canandaigua Lake
$$ • Restaurant, Steakhouse
Most Recent Reviews
Great food, service, and atmosphere! Our server was very knowledgeable and helpful in navigating the menu. Their main menu isn’t labeled but they have an allergen list online. They have GF bread available and have an amazing cauliflower flatbread!
Offer gluten free bun for the lobster roll! I forgot to ask if fries are in a separate fryer and didn’t eat them.
They have an allergen menu. We've eaten here twice with no issues. Excellent steaks.
Photos
More Reviews
Nice restaurant and friendly staff, but not knowledgeable about celiac. Very few menu items felt “safe.” Ordered a salad, explained celiac, and salad still came with croutons. Ended up not eating anything because I just wasn’t confident.
I've been to Nolan's several times. The wait staff is knowledgeable and accommodating. I've never had a reaction from eating there
Only allergy menu that you need to cross reference against main menu. Got salad with grilled chicken and got symptoms. I'm avoiding this place going forward.
They have knowledge of celiac. There’s an “allergy” setting on the ordering system, the waitress said. They serve Udi GF rolls.
Even though the waitress checked with the chef about the about the special of the day and was informed of the gluten allergy, she brought out a salad with croutons on it. I knew I was going to get glutened. Will not go back.
I ate here last weekend and had a burger on a GF bun with a side salad and felt fine after! This was after I had to send my side salad back because it came with croutons on it... I also had to ask the waitress what on the menu could be prepared GF (since their menu isn’t labeled) and she seemed to think that “anything” could be GF including pasta dishes that could be modified (although they don’t have GF pastas) When waitresses say things like that it always makes me hesitant that they actually don’t know what gluten is. I asked about the fries and she said they only fry their “sides” in the fryer but also couldn’t be sure. I chose a safe meal and was fine but I think your menu selection and your willingness to adventure into other menu selections depends on the knowledge of your server and you advocating for yourself.
Menu selection is fantastic and restaurant is beautiful.
They have messed up my order twice now. the second time, the recooked order was a very obvious revenge preparation. took longer to cook the do over by 2x and was the worst steak they could find, and about half the mashed potatoes as the original.
Good burgers, but no GF buns or anything. They gave me mine on a bed of lettuce with all the fixings, which worked out pretty well. Without a GF menu you're up to the mercy of their daily specials and your server. If you're here with company or need something in a pinch they do seem to take it pretty seriously though.
Great place to have a steak! No gf menu, but staff was very knowledgeable.
