Posh Pop Bakeshop
$$ • Bakery
Reported to be dedicated gluten-free
Most Recent Reviews
Fantastic experience with excellent service! My brain was literally overwhelmed with the abundance of amazing choices!! The sugar pretzel was delish and the chocolate sprinkle mini donuts. Cappuccino was great too!
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cupcakes, Cakes, Dessert, Donuts
I bought some donuts and they were pretty expensive and not very tasty to be honest. They were extremely dry and I ended up throwing them out. Might be bad luck, they had a wide selection but after the bad donuts I didn’t want to come back :-)
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Dessert, Donuts
So nice going to a Gluten Free bakery! My first pretzel and it was so good. The sweets selection was amazing.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cakes, Brownies, Apple Pie
From the owner
Posh Pop Bakeshop is the Best Family Owned and Operated Gluten Free Bakeshop in the World! Baking Fresh Desserts Like Tiramisu, Tres Leches Cake, Salted Caramel Cookies and So Much More! Our Specialty is Focused on Fresh Baked and Decorated Cakes! All Our Cakes are Made w/ the Best Buttercreams, Cream Cheese Frosting or Fresh Marshmallow Meringues. Our Cakes Range in size from 6" (Feeds 2-4), 8" (Feeds 10-12), 10" (Feeds 20-24) and 12" (Feeds 40-50). Orders can be placed for Same Day Pick Up or Local Delivery Via Uber Eats, Grubhub or Doordash. Go Ahead and Follow Us on Instagram for All the Lastest Desserts!
Photos
More Reviews
This is possibly the only gf bakery I’ve found where the pastries are not dry. They’re reasonably priced compared to other bakeries in the area. Definitely plan on making this my go-to in the city
Dedicated GF
Just amazing. Some of the best GF treats I’ve had since becoming gluten free. They have other allergens also clearly listed and as someone who’s dairy free as well I had SO many yummy options still. Also super friendly service and a welcoming vibe. HIGHLY recommend!
Dedicated GF
The best gluten free bakery!! I love the banana cheesecake in particular
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cupcakes, Cakes, Cheesecake, Dessert & more
Other
- — Good for dairy-free
This review is for location on 39th St. All gluten free bakery. Lots of pastries/baked goods. Very tasty. 100% celiac safe.
Dedicated GF
The best! Such a DELIGHT for a celiac!
Dedicated GF
Everything is gluten free and it’s very overwhelming but everything looks so good and i got fried oreos and they were great
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cake Balls, Pies, Funnel Cake, Dessert & more
Other
- — Good for alcohol-free
Really good! A little pricey but worth it. So many options! The staff were great & confirmed the whole place is GF, though always good to ask.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Carrot Cake, Cupcakes, Cakes, Brownies & more
Outstanding. I ordered a slice of the hot chocolate cake and the Nutella cookie pie for delivery to my hotel when I was staying in the city. They arrived quickly and both were delicious and generously sized.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cakes, Pies, Cookies
Other
- — Takeout
- — Good for breakfast
- — Delivery
- — Online ordering
Delicious. I had the apple cider donut and it was so good!!
Dedicated GF
yummy!
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Carrot Cake, Cakes, Tarts, Brownies & more
Other
- — Vegetarian options
Everything I tried was exceptional!!! Their baked goods really are next level and their lemonade is yummy too!
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cheesecake, Cookies
Lots of options for those with a sweet tooth! Cakes, cookies, bars, cinnamon buns, etc. The s’mores bar is delicious.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cakes, Funnel Cake, Donuts, Cookies & more
Wow!!! This place is amazing for those like me with celiac disease. I never thought I'd have delicious carrot cake or pumpkin pie again. It was so much fun to go to a bakery with every option being GF and no threat of cross contamination. Thank you Posh Pop Bakeshop.💖💖💖I can hardly wait to visit New York again❣I highly recommend this awesome bakery.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cupcakes, Tiramisu, Cake Balls, Funnel Cake & more
Ive never seen so many gluten free options in my entire life. so beautiful and yummy and magical
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cakes, Cake Balls, Pies, Brownies & more
Very fun place to go. Friendly people, willing to answer questions. Great variety of baked goods.
Dedicated GF
This place genuinely changed my life. Soft pretzels are the one thing I missed since diagnosis and I haven’t found anything remotely close until I came here. Everything is gluten free and other allergens are all clearly listed which is amazing. If you have any dessert craving, you will be satisfied here. Brownies, cheesecake, cinnamon bun, soft pretzels, funnel cake, cookies, cake, etc.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Funnel Cake, Cinnamon Rolls, Cheesecake, Cookies & more
Other
- — Good for dairy-free
Very yummy, lots of options! Very little indoor seating (only one bench).
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cupcakes, Tarts, Brownies, Cheesecake & more
It was great. So many options
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Brownies, Cheesecake, Donuts, Cookies & more
Other
- — Good for dairy-free
Amazing to have so many gluten free pastry & dessert options! 10/10 recommend the smores cookie
Dedicated GF
So many yummy choices and entirely gluten free. Churro funnel cake was amazing!
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cakes, Funnel Cake, Donuts, Cookies & more
So good and every thing was gf. Great service. Tons to choose from. We had a brookie, Samoa cookie, Boston cream cheesecake, chocolate donuts with sprinkles. Expensive but worth it.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Brownies, Cheesecake, Donuts, Cookies & more
Like most gluten-free bakeries, this place does not live up to the hype. Overpriced and not very good.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Dessert
LOVE THIS PLACE. The fried Oreos were insane. The carrot cake was out of this world.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Carrot Cake, Cakes
No words, incredible 👏🏼
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cakes, Cake Balls, Brownies, Cake Pops
Beautiful dedicated GF Bakery. For the sweet toothed!! Divine decedent desserts. Ordered up - Boston Cheesecake, Cinnamon Scroll, Salted Caramel Cookie, S’more brownie, S’mores Tart, Gingerbread cheesecake and a hot chocolate! Tasty - and the nonGF in the family also loved!!
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Brownies, Tarts, Cheesecake, Dessert & more
I could weep. First soft pretzel I've had in four years. Most things have dairy (I have a casein allergy but it's mild) but you can find things that don't. So good.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Pies, Cinnamon Rolls, Soft Pretzels
Other
- — Good for wheat-free
I love this bakery! It has such a great vibe. It's has a vintage feel to it. The staff there are so sweet and welcoming! I ordered the gluten free vegan apple pie. They heated it up for me and i inhaled it! My Brother who was with me and is not gluten-free, even enjoyed it. He loved their hot chocolate, too!
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cupcakes, Cake Balls, Funnel Cake, Cinnamon Rolls & more
Other
- — Dog friendly
- — Vegan options
- — Vegetarian options
- — Takeout
Choices galore, fantastic staff, delicious treats! Wish I didn’t live so far away! Although maybe that’s a good thing😉
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Brownies, Funnel Cake, Dessert, Churros & more
Fully gluten free and great.
Dedicated GF
Huge fan! It’s a celiac paradise where you are overwhelmed by excellent choices. I get my birthday cake from here every year. One thing I will say is that all the portions are ENORMOUS - and quite reasonably priced for celiac pastries.
Dedicated GF
Just yum. And they seem to have flours not made with oats. Amazing find! What took me so long?
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Carrot Cake, Tiramisu, Cinnamon Rolls, Dessert & more
So many options! Very flavorful and filling. I’m also dairy free and they have several treats I can enjoy. It is expensive but it’s a go to whenever I’m in the city!
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Pies, Funnel Cake, Cookies
Other
- — Good for dairy-free
Posh Pop is expensive but I would say it's worth it for a treat. They have all sorts of fun desserts, all gluten free. I got a peanut butter s'mores brownie that was quite good. The cake I tried from there was a solid 4/5.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cupcakes, Tarts, Funnel Cake, Cake Pops & more
Other
- — Vegetarian options
- — Takeout
- — Good for wheat-free
I return to this place frequently. While the desserts are remarkable, the prices have increased dramatically. If you compare their products to one of the top bakeries in New York, you will see that the prices are approximately twice the price of Magnolias bakery. Cakes are $125 for a cake or $12.50 per slice. Pies are $55. Cookies are $7.50. Dessert bars, like Blondies and cookie dough $10.50. While I like to support small businesses and understand that GF does cost more, it appears this place is gouging those of us who have limited options for desserts. Very disappointing. Unfortunately, I will probably be passing on this place going forward, not because I can’t afford it, but because I don’t think that it is fair for those who can’t afford it. If they get their prices back in line to normal levels, I will return.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cakes, Pies, Cinnamon Rolls, Churros & more
This is the best gluten free bakery I’ve ever been to. They had gluten free fried Oreos and fried funnel cake and more. It is total safe for Celiac. It has a great atmosphere and will brighten anyone’s day with Celiac.
Dedicated GF
Unreal. My jaw dropped to the floor when I walked in. I couldn’t get over the enormous selection and had to come back again a day later. Ultimately the smores bar and “samoa” cookie were the winners, but everything I tried was great.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Brownies, Cookies
Honestly a bit of a gluten free wonderland. Unfortunately, their prices are truly out of this world. Most of the portions are big, but still the prices are bigger! It’s a little disappointing since I always want to buy everything, but cannot afford to.
Dedicated GF
This is the greatest place I have absolutely ever been since celiac diagnosis 7 years ago. I hope every gluten free person gets to experience this place. Although pricey, every item I had was phenomenal and I had zero regrets. They have gluten free figured out. I got an apple cider donut, a strawberry pop tart, a cinnamon roll, and a Samoa cookie. (Also had a matcha latte that was delish). My favorite was the Samoa cookie and cider donut! Stock up when you go here it is absolutely worth every single penny.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cupcakes, Tiramisu, Tarts, Funnel Cake & more
Other
- — Good for soy-free
- — Good for brunch
- — Takeout
- — Good for kids
Died and went to gluten free heaven when I walked in here! Super nice staff and crazy selection. Do yourself a favor and get carrot cake, the sprinkle vanilla cake, banana pudding cheesecake, and churro fried Oreo!! My son also loved the s'mores bar and he didn't share any. Will be back soon.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Tiramisu, Sandwiches, Salad, Tarts & more
An unmissable stop for anyone who wistfully remembers the experience of walking into a fully-stocked, beautiful bakery where you can try everything… and not get sick. As always, a bit pricier than a regular bakery but worth the splurge! After a ton of deliberation, we grabbed apple cider donuts, a huge slice of chocolate peanut butter cake and for an few worthwhile extra minutes’ wait… cinnamon sugar funnel cake!!!
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cupcakes, Tiramisu, Tarts, Funnel Cake & more
We stopped for a ‘little’ treat after lunch. Overwhelmed by choice we decided to go for a best seller, the s’mores bar! It was fantastic!! I still dream about it
Dedicated GF
Came here all the way from Atlanta! My wife has celiac and we were blown away on all the stuff they had. We got the banana puddin cheesecake, red velvet cake, and a whole bunch more to take home. They have the best vanilla cake we ever had too! My wife got to have funnel cake for the first time we got the churro but we will be back to try the original one with powder sugar. I just ordered the s'mores bar box because them s'mores bars are legit!
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cakes, Funnel Cake, Cheesecake, Churros
Other
- — Takeout
- — Good for dairy-free
- — Delivery
- — Online ordering
We ended our NYC trip here, on a high note, and I broke the bank 😆 Many dairy free options. Everything labeled with allergens. Friendly and helpful staff. Huge variety. I love everything, especially the Ube cheesecake and peanut butter bar. Absolutely everything looks amazing.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cakes, Brownies, Cheesecake, Cake Pops & more
Other
- — Vegan options
- — Vegetarian options
- — Takeout
- — Good for kids
Yes, it’s pricey, but hey, it’s New York. I went to their new location on west 39th street, which is small but inviting. I ended up selecting the s’mores bar, which was very good! The graham crackers were buttery, not dry, which is impressive for gluten free. It was larger than I thought it would be, making the price a little more reasonable.
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Cupcakes, Cakes, Pies, Tarts & more
Other
- — Vegetarian options
- — Takeout
- — Good for kids
- — Good with other allergies
The best selection of gluten free desserts I have been to! I got the pumpkin cake with cream cheese frosting that’s super moist and delicious. Samoa cookie and the most decadent brownie with birthday sprinkle cheesecake on top! My sister and I also shared their churro fried oreo which was made fresh and served warm! Loved everyone here and will surely be back!
Dedicated GF
GF Menu Items
- — Pies, Pastries
Other
- — Vegetarian options
- — Good for brunch
- — Takeout
- — Dinner
So expensive even for gluten free. I wish the taste was improved it all sort of tastes the same despite varying flavors. I’ve since made some cheesecake at home, massive difference. I wanted to love this with everything in me, it’s just not tasting worth the price tag. Grateful for GF options, but will not be back.
Dedicated GF
Everything is gluten free, prices are high.
Dedicated GF
More Info
Nearby Restaurants
Similar Places in New York City
- Gluten-Free Cakes in New York City
- Gluten-Free Brownies in New York City
- Gluten-Free Cookies in New York City
- Gluten-Free Dessert in New York City
- Gluten-Free Cheesecake in New York City
- Gluten-Free Donuts in New York City
- Gluten-Free Pies in New York City
- Gluten-Free Cake Pops in New York City
- Gluten-Free Cinnamon Rolls in New York City
- Gluten-Free Cupcakes in New York City
