My kids are on gluten and casein free diets and I am allergic to cow dairy. I was delighted to see Buffalo mozzarella and Romano (sheep) cheese as an option. The server seemed skeptical but it came out without cow dairy or cross contamination (or I would be sick as a dog today). The kids had the gluten free pizza without cheese (just toppings) and it was excellent. This place is busy so you can expect a wait. Pizza came out quickly nonetheless but we got our own leftover boxes and waited a long time for the check. While they got it right, I'd be nervous if celiac. This place seems better for those with intolerances.
Best flourless chocolate cake I have ever had! I wanted to order a GF pizza but as soon as I mentioned to our server that I have a severe allergy, she was adamant that the kitchen was too full of gluten and that the pizza was not a safe option. I instead had a nice spinach bacon salad.
This delicious wood-fired pizza place is very much off the beaten track and does require a car ride to get to. However, for the glutenfree diner, I can promise you it's worth it. They have an extensive menu of specialty pizza options ranging from white pizza to sautéed vegetables, most of which can be made with a gluten-free crust. This place was probably my favorite meal of the entire trip. The food was delicious and the service was extremely accommodating. If you do find yourself down in the Key West area, make sure you put aside a night to seek out this hidden gem.