I would give them a 5 if I felt they really could really make things 100% celiac safe 100% of the time. They have awesome food and a great atmosphere and it's the only place I go in Waterbury. I either get a burger or salad with a protein. The kale salad is amazing. They will take precautions for you, but it's a kitchen with lots of gluteny options, so at times I've had some very minor symptoms a day or two later. I still keep going back though. They have gf beer and free popcorn.
they have several gluten free options including gluten free hamburger buns! they also have a few gluten free beer and hard cider options. Update 7/6/13 This place is still my go to for good food im central Vermont. I am celiac and very sensitive and have no problems with this place. The gfree buns are the best I've ever had- moist big and not crumbly. Very good burgers and the chipotle chicken sandwich is amazing. They also carry the best gfree craft beer made today - Harvester brewing. Very good restaurant. Only reason for 4 stars is that they don't have a separate gfree menu.