Gluten-Free Pies in Amityville, New York

Last updated January 2025

  • 1. Rustica Brick Oven Cafe

    94 ratings
    1 Nassau Blvd, Garden City, NY 11530
    $$ • Pizza Restaurant
    GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pies, Bread/Buns, Cakes, Calamari & more

    100% of 34 votes say it's celiac friendly

  • 2. The Pizzeria

    5 ratings
    591 Main St, Islip, NY 11751
    $ • Pizza Restaurant
    GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pies, Pasta, Pizza

    100% of 3 votes say it's celiac friendly

  • 3. Frantoni's

    12 ratings
    66 Hillside Ave, Williston Park, NY 11596
    $ • Italian Restaurant
    GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pies, Pasta, Pizza

    100% of 4 votes say it's celiac friendly

  • 4. Americano Pie Bar

    7 ratings
    517 Main St, Islip, NY 11751
    $$ • Restaurant
    No GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pies, Pasta

    50% of 4 votes say it's celiac friendly

  • 5. Sweet Karma Desserts, Inc.

    14 ratings
    136 Manetto Hill Rd, Plainview, NY 11803
    $ • Bakery
    No GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pies, Cookies, Dessert

    50% of 2 votes say it's celiac friendly

  • 6. West End Pizza & Restaurant

    3 ratings
    918 W Beech St, Long Beach, NY 11561
    $$ • Pizza Restaurant
    No GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pies, Pasta, Pizza

    66% of 3 votes say it's celiac friendly

  • 7. Alpine Pastry Shop

    6 ratings
    59 NY-111, Smithtown, NY 11787
    $ • Bakery
    GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pies, Bread/Buns, Cookies, Dessert & more

    66% of 3 votes say it's celiac friendly

  • 8. Bare Naked Bakery

    91 ratings
    164 Manetto Hill Rd, Plainview, NY 11803
    $$ • Bakery
    dedicated gluten-free badge Reported to be dedicated gluten-free

    Reported GF menu options: Apple Pie, Avocado Toast, Bagels, Baguettes & more

    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 9. Iavarone Brothers

    3 ratings
    1166 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793
    $ • Grocery Store
    No GF Menu
    100% of 3 votes say it's celiac friendly
    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 10. Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant

    5 ratings
    999 Montauk Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704
    $$ • Pizza Restaurant
    GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pasta, Pizza, Wings

    75% of 4 votes say it's celiac friendly
    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 11. Leonardo's Pizza

    2 ratings
    20 Broadway, Massapequa, NY 11758
    $$ • Pizza Restaurant
    GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pasta, Pizza

    100% of 2 votes say it's celiac friendly
    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 12. Bellagio Pizza Restaurant

    7 ratings
    211 Airport Plaza Blvd, Farmingdale, NY 11735
    $$ • Pizza Restaurant
    No GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pizza

    66% of 6 votes say it's celiac friendly
    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 13. Park Bake Shop

    10 ratings
    112 NY-25A, Kings Park, NY 11754
    $ • Bakery
    No GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Bread/Buns, Cakes, Cookies, Cupcakes

    100% of 9 votes say it's celiac friendly
    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 14. No Gluten Kneaded

    60 ratings
    1089 Smithtown Ave, Bohemia, NY 11716
    $ • Bakery
    dedicated gluten-free badge Reported to be dedicated gluten-free

    Reported GF menu options: Bagels, Bread/Buns, Cookies, Dessert & more

    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 15. Rosemarie's

    3 ratings
    188 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, NY 11735
    $$ • Restaurant
    No GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pizza

    66% of 3 votes say it's celiac friendly
    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 16. Mary's Pizza & Pasta

    9 ratings
    876 Connetquot Avenue, Islip Terrace, NY 11752
    $ • Pizza Restaurant
    GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pizza

    100% of 8 votes say it's celiac friendly
    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 17. Kerber's Farm

    5 ratings
    309 W Pulaski Rd, Huntington, NY 11743
    $ • Specialty Store
    GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Biscuits, Bread/Buns, Brownies, Dessert & more

    100% of 2 votes say it's celiac friendly
    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 18. Glenn Wayne Wholesale Bakery

    27 ratings
    1800 Artic Ave, Bohemia, NY 11716
    $ • Bakery
    GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Dessert, Donuts

    100% of 3 votes say it's celiac friendly
    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 19. Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

    3 ratings
    4180 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Bohemia, NY 11716
    $$ • Pizza Restaurant
    No GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pizza, Wings

    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 20. Carlo's Pizza Of Roslyn

    1 rating
    350 Roslyn Rd, Roslyn Heights, NY 11577
    $$ • Pizza Restaurant
    No GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pizza

    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 21. Rocco's Pizza

    4 ratings
    253 Medford Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772
    $$ • Pizza Restaurant
    No GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pizza

    100% of 3 votes say it's celiac friendly
    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 22. La pizzeria and bagel

    1 rating
    951 Rosedale Rd, Valley Stream, NY 11581
    $ • Pizza Restaurant
    GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pasta, Pizza

    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 23. Abeetza Pizza

    3 ratings
    82 Glen Cove Rd, Greenvale, NY 11548
    $ • Pizza Restaurant
    No GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Bread/Buns, Pizza

    50% of 2 votes say it's celiac friendly
    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 24. Ble Cafe & Bakery

    1 rating
    63-65 Main St, Port Washington, NY 11050
    $ • Bakery
    No GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Cookies, Cupcakes, Dessert, Macarons

    Pies is mentioned in comments

  • 25. Carlo's Pizza

    1 rating
    74-02 Metropolitan Ave, Middle Village, NY 11379
    $ • Pizza Restaurant
    GF Menu

    Reported GF menu options: Pizza

    Pies is mentioned in comments
Full Screen Map

Easily find gluten-free pies near you by downloading our free app.

Download it on the App Store
Get it on Google Play

Gluten-Free Features

Categories

Looking for more?
Eating gluten-free in New York