Brewster's Italian Cafe

4.5 stars 4.5 out of 5 11 ratings
$$Celiac Friendly, Pizza, Pasta + 4 more
80% of 5 votes say it's Celiac friendly

11 West Merchant Street, New Buffalo, MI 49117

(269) 469-3005
  • User profile picture thumbnail
    4 ratingMay 06, 2017

    Check the hours on their website before going. It seems to vary. Had a gluten free pizza which was amazing.

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    5 ratingFebruary 19, 2017

    Very knowledgeable waitress, GF pasta was a hit. Many GF items.

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    3 ratingJuly 23, 2016

    Food here is tasty but NOT celiac safe (but may be ok for intolerant). Celiac members got glutened despite attempts by kitchen to be safe (pizzas served on same wicker serving trays as regular pizza's).

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    5 ratingNovember 05, 2015

    My favorite place we ate at on our vacation to New Buffalo. Delicious pasta (one of the best GF pasta's I had) and great pizza. Plus delicious dessert. I love when I don't feel short changed by the GF options, and I certainly didn't here! Side note bonus: also, surprisingly kid friendly!

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    4 ratingAugust 13, 2015

    They understood my diet and I was able to eat here safely. I ate pasta. Not the best I ever had but it was fine. I was happy to have the option for sure! Oh and dessert too! Next time pizza!

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    5 ratingAugust 05, 2015

    Very tasty, nice, and relaxing place for lunch. I'm Celiac and had no problem with the GF pizza I ordered. Other options were GF pasta and salads. My husband had non-GF food and enjoyed it, too. We will return when we are in town again.

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    5 ratingNovember 04, 2014

    Have always loved this restaurant. Not as fantastic since it has switched hands, but still really delicious. They have GF pizza crust, pasta & a couple of GF dessert options. Staff is knowledgeable and even remembered to leave croutons off the salad when I had forgotten to mention! Great date place.

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    5 ratingMarch 01, 2014

    Great gluten free options! Pizza is so authentic! Staff is very friendly! Love this place.

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    5 ratingJune 21, 2013

    I had the gluten free pizza and the salad appetizer, they also have two gluten free desserts available! A fabulous meal and I would highly recommend!

Gluten-Free Features

  • Celiac Friendly
  • Dessert
  • Pasta
  • Pizza


  • Cafe
  • Italian
  • Lunch
11:30 am - 10 pm
11:30 am - 10 pm
11:30 am - 10 pm
11:30 am - 10 pm
11:30 am - 11 pm
11:30 am - 11 pm
11:30 am - 10 pm

Be the first to add a photo!

Nearby restaurants

Do you own a gluten-free friendly business?
Contact us to talk about your advertising options.