Carnegie Pizza
$ • Pizza Restaurant
Most Recent Reviews
The guys did a great job with my pizza. Their gluten free crust was baked on a separate tray. Gloves were used and separate utensils. They also gave me a disposable pizza cutter with my pizza so there was no cross contamination. I didn’t get sick and I’m very sensitive.
10 inch gluten free pizza base available. Big enough for two. Cooked on a clean foil tray but in the same oven as normal pizzas. Tasted a bit cakey, but ok! No ill effects after!
Not careful with Gluten Free separation (no gloves, same equipment) the crust tastes terrible in comparison to other places. Not worth going to.
Photos
More Reviews
Amazing pizza with a crispy crust. They let me choose toppings, and cooked it fresh on the spot. I was also given a packaged pizza cutter to cut my pizza. 10/10 would recommend!!
Gluten free personal was $18 versus $3 for a regular slice, the crust was thin but tasty.
I will say they did have gluten free crust that is prepackaged and put on new gloves but not at all celiac safe. They grabbed cheese and toppings from same places as gluten pizza and were not very informed or patient when I was asking if it was safe for my sister
Did not wash hands. Wiped hands with a used wipe, made my pizza next to a huge bowl of flour, used bare hands straight into toppings that had been used with normal pizzas. I was too scared to eat the pizza so i didn’t. I can confirm that the pizza crust itself did appear to be sealed well, along with the pizza cutter, but right when the employee opened it, i lost all hope.
The best gluten free place I’ve eaten ate. Visiting NY I was so saddened with the lack of celiac knowledge though this place are incredible and very thoughtful in being aware of CC. Pizza was cooked on a disposable tray and I was given my own sealed pizza cutter which was labeled “gluten free”. Lovely service also.
Thank you! Gluten free pizza cooked on a separate disposable pan, with a sealed plastic pizza cutter. Good gf crust.
Gluten free pizza crust was delicious! Since it's made at the same ingredient station as the regular pizza I'd worry about cross contamination but otherwise excellent.
Very safe! The gf pizzas are 14” individual pies that are cooked in a separate pan - and they give you a plastic pizza slicer so they don’t contaminate it! The crust is pretty good for a gf, New York style pizza. The sauce was amazing and sooo cheesy! Delicious.
Good pizza and served with a separate, packaged cutter! They say it’s personal but it definitely serves 2.
Amazing NY style gf pizza. If you want authentic NY style pizza, this is the place to go.
Great pizza! They took the crush out of its own packaging, cleaned the area and used fresh toppings (2 are included for your pizza) and cooked it in the oven (was around other pizza but wasn’t a problem for me). Then when it was ready, they gave me my own pizza cutter to use! Tasted great and will come back!!
This was such a treat! Midnight GF pizza just off of Time’s Square! Made to order. BIG GF pizzas! And we even had a dedicated pre-wrapped pizza slicer! Had to ask about Gluten Free and one server had to remind our server that something we asked about was not GF. It was delicious and none of us had any issues! They knew the deal!
I was nervous about cross contamination but I was greatly relieved. The gluten free crust comes in its own tray and they give you a wrapped cutter for the pizza. You do have to order the full pizza so no by the slice. Not my favorite pizza but satisfying. There is a slight vanilla or sweetness to the crust but it’s not overpowering.
