Jay's Deli

3.0 stars 3.0 out of 5 4 ratings
$$Pizza, Bread/Buns, Cookies + 4 more
50% of 2 votes say it's Celiac friendly

534 New York 32, Highland Mills, NY 10930 Directions

(845) 928-2803
  • User profile picture thumbnail
    1 rating Not celiac friendly
    7 months ago

    Worst service in the world. Don’t get me wrong, food is great. However, about 95% of the staff looks miserable and are very rude.

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    3 rating
    3 years ago

    One of the better gf pizzas I've had, but stopped eating it after getting sick from cross contamination.

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    4 rating Celiac friendly
    4 years ago

    Good pizza, my boyfriend said it was kind of like Pizza Hut crust. I personally prefer thin-crust, but if you like it a bit more substantial this is the best for you. You get a nice sized pie for $15 (two of us ate it and were stuffed)

  • User profile picture thumbnail
    4 rating
    4 years ago

    Jay's is a local deli that has been adding a number of g-free items to their regular grocery stock-pasta, pancake mix, cookies, crackers, soups, snacks. They also now have a g-free freezer with breads, desserts, etc. Definitely worth noting, they sell prepared g-free pizza which, I might add, is quite good (and foldable!). The crust is cooked all the way through and the flavor is good. They prepare the pizza separately on its own tray. I've eaten it many times and never had an issue. They are now selling the pizza by the slice too! Every time I go in here, I find something new I can choose from. Over Memorial Day weekend, I found that they were making full sized cakes g-free too...nicely decorated and with a normal price tag!! My entire family (none of them are gf) loved the cake too! That's the big test.My only complaint-they make a g-free pasta salad but they keep it in the same case as everything else, so there may be some cross contamination issues...it seems they are still learning...which explains a four not five star review.Go to Jays! You'll be happy you stopped in.

Gluten-Free Features

  • Bread/Buns
  • Cookies
  • Pizza


  • Deli
  • Lunch
  • Takeout
  • Vegetarian Friendly
5 am - 9 pm
5 am - 9 pm
5 am - 9 pm
5 am - 9 pm
5 am - 9 pm
5 am - 9 pm
5 am - 5 pm
  • maps.google.com/?cid=17523112417488184953

Be the first to add a photo!

Nearby restaurants

Do you own a gluten-free friendly business?
Contact us to talk about your advertising options.