I love when places include gluten free options in local food so we don't feel left out. I was so excited I got to try gluten free key lime pie with my husband and it didn't disappoint! The tartness of the key lime is balanced really well with the cream they have on the top and the texture was super smooth. They sell single gf slices and whole gf pies. They also have gf key lime pie on a stick, but I was trying to behave so I didn't try it. We did try another gf key lime pie and I liked Kermits the best. Cute store and friendly staff.
— Not Much
Amazing GF key lime pie! Did not get sick and labeled in separate container!
— No gluten-free information on the menu
Love the GF pie....I just wish they they were a little more friendly in there!
Very good gf keylime pie. Got the last piece at 9pm
Gluten free key lime pie, crust was amazing! Could have just eaten that by itself!
Nima found gluten in their gluten free key lime pie. Pic posted.
Tried the GF key lime pie. They make them with the GF cookies that they sell in the store and all ingredients are gluten free. Delicious
Delicious GF key lime pie. I’ll go back again this week!
Delicious gluten free key lime pie! Individually packaged and definitely worth the price. No reaction so all was well.
Gluten free Key lime pie is good. It’s thick and rich and they use the gf cookies for the crust. Gf cookies were 9.95 for 6 oz, so we didn’t try them.
GF key lime pie was delicious!
Great GF key lime pie! Perfect ratio of sweet and sour.
Just loved it. Dense, tart, and lots of flavor. They have cookies too. Best in KW and I tried them all.
Excellent! This was our favorite key lime pie on Key West. The texture was creamy and the flavor wasn’t overly sour.
Not the first to note but keep walking when you hit Kermit's. Key West Key Lime has superior GF pie.
But!!! Kermit's gets a big thumbs up for having GF, it's not bad, and they do also have some really good GF key lime cookies.
Great gf key lime pie, would try again
Amazing little shop! This was such a treat! They use their key lime sugar cookies for the crust! Gluten free and delicious!!
Wonderful to be included in the Key Lime pie. And it was great.
Amazing fresh gluten free key lime pie!! Had a GF graham cracker crust and everything :)
Got the gluten free key lime pie. You can check the ingredients of the crust on the GF cookies. Did not get me sick. Yummy!!
Amazing gluten free Key Lime pie!
Gluten free Key Lime pie and candies. Delicious and great atmosphere.
I was excited to have a slice of key lime pie in the keys!! Flavor was great and rice crust was good.
Amazing amazing amazing. Can't say it enough.
Fairly good pie and good service.
So good! Gluten free key lime pie, fresh or frozen slices.
Went here 7 NIGHTS IN A ROW...for they AMAZING gf Key Lime pie! Even met the owner, Kermit...GREAT guy!!
Awesome Gluten Free pie- the cream on top was the best! I also bought some of their Gluten Free powdered cookies and they are so delicious!
Great pie!! Had 2 slices :)
Amazing!! I ate a piece everyday of our 3 day trip... Actually I ate 2 on the last day!! You can pre-order a whole gf pie for $30.
So excited to finally find a key lime pie place that offers gluten free! Absolutely delicious!
Fantastic! Super friendly. Yummy key lime pie!
Delicious! 2 locations - both wonderful.
I had a slice of GF key lime pie every night of our trip. I deviated to Kermit's once,and I was sorry I had. Key Lime Pie Co's is much better. It didn't have the bitter aftertaste that many key lime pie's (and Kermit's) do and the GF version had a proper graham cracker crust on it, instead of Kermit's rice-based crust (which was so hard after being in the freezer that i couldnt even eat it). Also, Key Lime Pie company cuts your slice when you order it. Don't make the same mistake I did :-/ only gets two stars because if I hadnt had Key Lime Pie Co's first, I might have thought it was "ok for being Gf".
Very nice to be able to eat GF Key Lime Pie. They have a great Koi fish pond.
2 stars for having a gluten free option, BUT Key West Key Lime Pie Co. Is a mich better option! The crust is amazing, and they offer chocolate dipped, something Kermits does not offer.. Key West Key Lime Pie Co. Also offers gluten free cookies, brownies, and cupcakes! I highly recommend skipping Kermits and going straight for Key West Key Lime Pie Co.!!
Flavor and crust were not that great but for having celiac I want to give it good reviews for being safe!
filling is very airy with good flavor but rice pastry crust is much too thick and undercooked... would be much better with gf graham cracker crust... doesn't come close to my key lime pie ; )
Delicious! I've never had key lime pie so nothing else to compare to but it's my boyfriend's favorite dessert and he was impressed with the GF version.
More tangy than Key West pie. Rice base crust is also strong. I opted to not eat the crust. too thick in the rice flour taste, which I'm not partial to rice flour. Key West pies crust is more "graham cracker" style and compliments the creamy texture of the Key lime filling, for my taste.
Great gluten free key lime pie!!! Felt great afterwards. The GF slices are frozen so I let it thaw for a couple minutes :)
Delicious with a rice based crust!
Gf key lime pie
Lovely garden to sit and enjoy GF KEY LIME PIE!!
Delicious!!! (I did not even wait for it to "unfreeze"!)
Met Kermit the chef and thanked him personally for making sure that we celiacs can enjoy key lime pie, too while visiting Key West.
I highly recommend getting a piece or two.
NOTE: not all his products are GF, so be careful what you sample. He has them labeled.
The key lime pie was amazing and the owner was very friendly and understanding of celiac disease. The garden was beautiful too. If you want g-free dessert and a wonderful atmosphere I recommend going.
Make sure to visit the Elizabeth Street location since they don't carry GF at the Duval location. The GF Key Lime Pie slices are frozen and there's a patio outside where you can hang out and eat. This was my only GF dessert for the trip!
Kermit's now has a gluten free key lime pie! I have had a delicious slice 3 days in a row with no ill side affects. I do react to very small amounts of gluten so I think they must be careful. I typically avoid eating out because of cross contamination making me so ill but when your on vacation you have to eat somewhere and when you are in Key West you want Key Lime Pie!!! Thank you Kermit! He also has gluten free Key lime peanuts and they are good! I hope to see more choices next trip!