We stumbled upon this place on accident and found the most delicious gluten free key lime pie!!! It was so delicious we came back to buy a whole gluten free pie to share with the family!
What a wonderful place. I stopped for the key lime pie on a stick; which was wonderful. But also found out the majority of their ice cream flavors are GF; the standard ones with cookies and cake aren’t however they make special GF pints of those. They also have whole GF key lime pies and all of their chocolates are gluten free. We will definitely be back!
I cannot say enough just how amazing their GF frozen key lime pie on a stick is. We got one on most days of our week-long trip, and would have taken more home if we could have. Also had several of their GF ice cream flavors, and those were also delicious.
Also ran into them at Island Fest in Islamorada, and they even brought some of the GF pies (frozen and non) despite the limited booth space available. That’s dedication.
I had them cater gluten free deserts for my wedding. They had amazing customer service and super good cookies and key lime pie.
Cheerful young man at counter was knowledgeable about gluten free. He said that one of the owners is gluten-free in her diet. Amazingly, about half of the ice cream options are gluten-free. There are two types of gluten-free cones, as well. I may have to return for the frozen , chocolate-covered, gluten-free Key lime pie on a stick.
The gluten-free key lime pie on a stick ( dipped in chocolate) may be the best gf dessert I’ve ever had. Truly perfect. I will be returning for more! They have quite the selection of chocolates and desserts. So glad we stopped by. Also got the key lime fudge to take back home ❤
We loved the gluten-free Key Lime Pie covered in chocolate on a stick! Also got the gluten-free honey bell buds, very good candy! They have gluten-free ice-cream and cones, however they do use the same scoops for all the ice cream. The person working offered to wash one for us, but we explained that the gluten-free ice cream would be cross contaminated from the previous scoops being used. So we got the gluten-free Key Lime Pie on a stick-they we’re great!
We have two children with celiac and we felt completely comfortable eating the gluten free key lime pie and frozen chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick!! They came pre packaged and labeled! They were delicious and the highlight of our trip. Highly recommend!! Also, my other daughter has a tree nut allergy and the employee was happy to go check on the safety of the Oreo ice cream sandwich for her (it was safe). It’s just amazing how the effort of some can ease the stress of traveling with restrictions.
Had the gluten free Key Lime pie which was fantastic!! I was so glad I could partake in the local delicacy! They had a good number of gluten free offerings including ice cream cones. To look at their website you wouldn’t know that they had any of these but it’s definitely worth a visit especially for the pie. Oh! They also had frozen Key Lime pie slice on a stick. I’ll try that one next time!
My husband and I were visiting key largo and stopped at this ice cream shop. The girl who helped us was very knowledgeable regarding gluten as her mom is also celiac and made sure to explain the possibility of cross contact and sanitized the scoop prior to serving us. Went there twice! Would recommend!
This business advertises they have dairy free and gluten free but all they had was sherbet. The key lime pies were in a cooler with a GF sign and when I asked if that’s all they had, they told me those weren’t GF. They said they usually have a few items but they didn’t when I stopped. It’s a bummer but even more so when it’s advertised and they don’t have it.
Wonderful experience and food. Staff had food clearly labeled and I loved the Key Lime Pie. Only place I could find a GF choice on this and it was excellent.
The key lime pie was delicious! Grateful for so many GF options!!
Delicious GF key lime pie! Unlike the Blonde Giraffe slightly south of this place, it has a crust. You can get a slice for $5, or a whole pie for $23
They have gluten free ice cream cones and excellent home made ice cream. The young kids staffing the counter were not the most helpful or informed but the owners have good procedures in place to prevent cross contamination of the ice cream. They also have GF key lime pie (we did not try). For dairy free they had a key lime sorbet which was excellent.
Gluten free key lime pie with cracker bottom was delicious!!!! Worth every bite.