Awesome selection of ciders and the turkey with Gouda cheese panini was delicious. They have a separate press to avoid cross contamination. The kettle popcorn was also excellent. I am glad I don't live in Rochester - my daughter goes to U of R - as I would probably spend too much time sampling all the ciders. I will definitely be back there for parent weekend.
Pretty good food (I had a standard ham and havarti panini on Gluten Free bread with cucumber dill salad. No complaints!). They have a separate panini press, change their gloves, do not use the same prep surfaces or the same knives to prep. Portions are decently sized. The seasonal kettle corn is amazing. $5 gets you a huge bag. But the real star at Müllers is the cider, and it's absolutely worth the stop. Dozens of varieties from NYS and beyond, and a variety of styles including some that I'd never had the opportunity to try in the US sometime. Try the Spanish Sidra for something very different! The bartender was incredibly nice and did a great job finding ciders that met my personal preferences. If you're like me and have found ciders to be a great substitution for beer in your life, Müllers is a can't-miss stop when in Rochester.