We eat at Pastoli's a few times a month and I have never gotten sick. The one time we had a problem with the order (pizza was made with a regular crust instead of a gluten free crust) they remade it quickly and the owner came out and apologized in person. They have the best fries and the sandwiches are really good. I don't think the pizza is amazing, but I appreciate that they have such a great GF selection and seem to take making their GF products very seriously.
Update: I originally posted this review three years ago and we have gotten Pastoli's almost every week since then and I have never gotten sick. I really appreciate that I have a safe place to pick up food on those busy days when I don't want to cook!
— Very
— Separate gluten-free menu
— Most/All
— Good