Paulie Gee's Logan Square
$$ • Restaurant
Most Recent Reviews
Love their gf Detroit style pizza! I’ve been here three times and every server I’ve had asks about food allergies. Very knowledgeable and can answer questions about the menu. Only the Detroit style pizza can be made gluten free. The salads can also be modified to be gluten free as well. Never been sick, and have felt safe eating here.
I’ve never been able to enjoy a gluten free Detroit style pizza before but it was SO GOOD! I love how fluffy the crust is. I had a pepperoni pizza on a gluten free crust and ate nearly the entire thing in one sitting. I was glad that mine came out with a lil ‘gluten free’ sign on it to differentiate it from my friends’ orders. Did not have a negative reaction and would definitely come back here again.
Love this place! A go-to and have never gotten sick.
Photos
More Reviews
One of the best gf pizzas I’ve had. The food comes out with a gf label. I’ve eaten hear several times now and not gotten sick. Also great for vegan options!
Hands down the best gluten free pizza there is. I’ve never had better No reactions ever after coming here. Knowledgeable about allergies. They have vegan cheese and it’s 11/10! 🔥🔥🔥
This shit right here is GOOOD! Finally some pizza that isn't thin and cardboard flavored! If you come here, get it DETROIT STYLE! And maybe add extra cheese if you're feelin it 🥰
Excellent Detroit style pizza crust. Server asked about any allergies when ordering and noted it on the order. Pizza came out with a flag that said “Gluten Free”. Only so many Detroit crusts in stock on a given night so it’s a first come first serve.
I have eaten here twice and had reactions both times. I cannot eat the caputo flour that they use.
I’ve eaten and Paulie Gee’s many times and never had a reaction. The servers are attentive to celiac. The gluten free pizzas are delicious - among the best GF pizza I’ve had.
I am VERY sensitive to gluten and for that reason I have never eaten pizza from a pizza restaurant before. After reading the raving reviews on this app I decided to give this place a try. When we ordered the waiter said she made it very clear to the chefs that my order is to be made with allergy handling to eliminate cross-contact. They only do the pan pizzas gluten free so there’s no risk of them being cooked on the same surface as the wheat flour pizzas. When the pizza came out it was labeled gluten free and they were beautiful. They looked so good I was almost afraid to eat them. I got even more scared because when I took a bite it was probably the best pizza I’ve had in my entire life. And I DIDN’T get sick!! Can’t wait to go back! Oh and no need to worry when you see the chefs in the front kitchen making the wheat flour pizzas with all the wheat flour (as my husband and I did). They make all of the gluten free pizzas in the back.
Incredible gluten free pizza. I’m also dairy free and it’s hard to find a good vegan cheese. Their Detroit style pizza is so good. However it’s very greasy so it was a bit hard on my sensitive stomach.
Great experience! Been excited to try this place for a while and definitely lived up to the hype. Server was extremely knowledgeable and the pizza was soooo fluffy. Will definitely be back
No idea why I put off coming here for so long! One of the best gluten free pizzas I’ve had in a while and I did not get sick. I’m extremely sensitive so always nervous trying a new place for the first time. Will be coming back!
Couldn’t be happier with my experience here! I got the carnivore pizza on a gluten free crust with vegan cheese, and it was delicious. The dish was marked as gluten free when it came out, and the waitress was very knowledgeable about the allergens and even reassured us that she spoke with the kitchen staff about it. Didn’t get the slightest bit sick, and I usually do from any cross contamination. My only recommendation is asking for extra sauce if you get this pizza if you’re a sauce lover like me. 10/10 will be back again!
Loooove this pizza!! I have shared with non-GF friends and they raved about it as well. Waiter was knowledgeable and noted I had celiac. I had a suspicion that they used my favorite GF flour, caputos flour, and I asked and was right! This flour is NOT wheat free but is gluten free, so if you have a wheat allergy not the place just FYI.
I have eaten here three times. Every time I’ve felt safe and did not get sick. I am celiac & sensitive to cc. I always get the pepperoni Detroit style pizza, with or without cheese stuffed crust. DELICIOUS! My favorite pizza!
NOT SAFE FOR CELIAC. Most delicious pizza. Definitely cross contamination. NIMA sensor came back 2x gluten found in their dough. Bummer. They do not make claims of non cross contamination, so non celiacs, enjoy! I only NIMA test foods that are delicious and 'seem too good to be true' when findmeGF has high ratings. Got so sick.
I didn’t think this pizza was impressive or worth the money. The sauce was awful, super flavorless. I’ve had much much better gluten free pizza. I didn’t get sick though and they offer gluten free and vegan pizza.
Incredible pizza, they were good about keeping mine in a separate station.
Best GF pizza in Chicago, no question. Amazing. Did not get sick.
This pizza was the best pizza I have ever had. Since becoming a celiac in 2007 i have not been able to enjoy a pizza with a little “weight” to it and that was cardboard thin.
I have celiac and have severe reactions and felt very safe eating it. The owner has perfected the recipe for a couple years and it is amazing! This is a must go!
Fantastic gluten free crust! We had their Detroit-style pizza, which has a really thick crust. The owner’s wife is celiac and they make their own GF dough in-house. Definitely recommend!
I’ve eaten their pizza at least 5x and always have a positive experience. I have celiac and am super sensitive to cross contact so I rarely feel safe eating pizza at restaurants that aren’t dedicated GF. They knock it out of the park every time & I’ve never once had symptoms after eating here. Plus, the crust is thick & fluffy…so delicious & I love their vegan cheese too.
It’s so hard to get good, no I’ll call it real, pizza for Celiacs especially adding on dairy restrictions for some of my crew. The team at Paulie Gee’s has taken time to perfect a Detroit style pie that is second to none. They take celiac seriously and while not a dedicated gf facility, use different tools, cutting boards, pans. Additionally, they limit which pies are available as GF so that they can reduce the risk of cross contamination. That’s all I can as for from my perspective. I didn’t feel the least bit sick eating there. They offer unique and very high quality toppings, the sauce is exceptional a hint of sweetness. It’s a bit pricey but you get what you pay for and I’d gladly shell out for their pizza anytime I’m anywhere near one of their locations. I truly thank their team from the bottom of my heart for a meal that nearly brought a tear to my eye is so was so exceptional. Hope everyone has a similar experience!
Their GF pizza is amazing! I'm allergic to gluten & dairy, and their GF pizza with vegan cheese is the best I've ever had! When I developed my allergies I figured I'd never get to have deep dish pizza again because most GF crust is super thin, but their Detroit style pizza is incredible!! The menu was clearly marked & my server was super knowledgable. My pizza was cooked in the same woodfire oven, but on a small individual baking rack so everything was kept seperate! I can't wait to go back! I literally asked my server to thank the guys in the kitchen for making such great pizza. Highly recommend!
Hands down the best GF pizza I’ve had! Even my non-celiac boyfriend eats it with no complaints. I’m very sensitive to traces of gluten from cross contamination, and I’ve never once had an issue after eating here (we eat here pretty often). In the GF world where Chicago deep dish is a fond memory and a lot of the GF pizza crust options are thin cauliflower crusts, their Detroit style thick crust is a God-send!
Gluten free dough available in the Detroit style. Owners tested recipes for 8 months, using their celiac friend as a tester. AMAZING ingredients, quality, texture, etc. So amazing. There are also vegan and vegetarian options!
