None of the pizza is celiac safe. They use a shared oven and place oven directly in oven, and are not able to use a dedicated pan/tray or foil. We asked 3 times if there was anyway to place a barrier and confirm they put GF pizza in the same surface as gluten pizza. So all GF pizza is placed directly on the shared oven with gluten pizza. Very disappointed celic kiddo. Not celiac safe. š
— Not at all
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Amazing pizza, great service. FMGF Community did it again - great recommendation. This was a fantastic spot. We will be back for sure.
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
Had a fabulous gluten free pesto pizza and met the owner. He has a pride in serving quality gluten free authentic Italian pizza mmm wood burning pizza. A definite stop when. Your in New York.
— Very
— Excellent
good and very large pizza, but $4 more for gluten free
— Somewhat
— Some
— Good
Best GF pizza I’ve had! Staff very knowledgeable and helpful. Made recommendations and told what menu items were GF. All but 2 pizzas could be made GF. Some salads and dessert options for GF too. Pasta dishes were not because of the homemade noodles.
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
Fantastic authentic pizza made in a brick oven. The service was great and the gluten-free focaccia was a rare treat.
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
All pizzas as gf, really good
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
I got the gluten free pizza with spicy salami and it was very good. I like my pizza extra crispy and forgot to mention that when I ordering. This was definitely in my top 10 and has potential to move to the top 5 if it was crispier. I highly recommend it and will definitely go back there again, two thumbs up!!! šš
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
Pizza tasted AMAZING, but I was violently sick a few hours later while trying to enjoy the concert at Radio City that I flew in for. Very disappointed.
— Not at all
We ordered gluten free pizza for my daughter who we told is a coeliac. 3 hours later we are at the airport and she is being violently sick which is always the case if she accidentally has gluten. Would avoid if a coeliac
— Not at all
— Separate gluten-free menu
— Below Average
Holy cow! So delicious! I ordered the PizzArte and it did not disappoint at all. This pizza was big enough for two with butternut squash, sausage and mozzarella. Fantastic! As a bonus, my whole family, who are not GF, loved their food as much as I loved mine!!
— Very
— Most/All
— Excellent
Excellent gf pizza. Everything was very clean and our lunch was delicious.
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
Pizza was so good I cannot attest to safety but good for intolerant
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
With a “gluten free” flag on their pizza, they happily brought us a “gluten free” pizza and we felt safe having our daughter try their pizza. She is now throwing up. She does have celiac but is not sensitive enough to throw up when just in a flour filled environment. She has to actually ingest glutinous flour in order to get sick. This place lied straight to our faces. I can’t believe it’s listed on this website as a recommendation!!!
— Not at all
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Not Much/None
— Poor
I was encouraged by the high number of positive reviews and tried this restaurant when many other places were closed on the Fourth of July. This pizza tasted very good and the staff seemed knowledgeable and conscientious about modifications for Celiac Disease. I definitely felt safe while eating it , but unfortunately, I had a violent Celiac reaction after eating at this restaurant. (One of the worst I’ve had in years!) So disappointing, because I do believe they were trying hard to keep things gluten free.
— Not very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
Best gluten free restaurant pizza I have ever had. Celiac safe
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
Great pizza! I loved their pesto so much! They had all their pizzas available to be gluten free and are very confident in handling celiac disease. It is a little on the pricier side your going to want to get tap water and no fancier drinks but we’ll worth it!
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
Very good gluten free pizza!
— Separate gluten-free menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
Amazing gluten free pizza. Assured me everything was safe and it was! Try this pizza if you eat gluten free š
— Very
— No gluten-free information on the menu
— Not Much/None
— Excellent
Both myself and my daughter are coeliac and ate here with no problem. Pizza’s were delicious, base was more or less like a normal one and was the same size as everyone else’s instead of the usual 10 inch for the same price as a normal 16.
— Very
— Most/All
— Excellent
Delicious GF pizza. Fresh and tasty and felt v safe. Would definitely recommend!
— Somewhat
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
Margarita Pizza
— Very
— Separate gluten-free menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
I ate here twice during my trip to New York! They are very knowledgeable of celiac and assured me that my pizza and focaccia bread (both so delicious!!) would be cooked without any risk of cross contamination. A little bit on the pricey side, but so worth it!
— Very
— Separate gluten-free menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
The GF pizza is so good it’s indistinguishable from a gluten pizza. I have yet to find a pizza as good as this one. We also had the Burrata which was delicious as well the artichoke salad (with arugula and Parmesan cheese). All were outstanding. For dessert we have the flourless chocolate cake which was okay but not memorable.
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
amazing gf pizza with really good dough!!!! it tastes like real pizza dough so its worth the gf upcharge imo!!! also loved the art and ambiance! slayed
— Somewhat
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
Amazing gluten free pizza!!!!𤩠one of The best I have ever tasted. Also very nice waiters!
— Very
— Most/All
— Excellent
This was the best gluten free pizza we have ever eaten. Our celiac family member was without symptoms. We would dine here again in a heartbeat!
— Very
— Most/All
— Excellent
Delicious pizza- my non-celiac family preferred the gf crust. Relatively quick service. Great little place to eat before a Broadway show.
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Good
Good but a bit pricey. Up charge for GF crusts. Cooked in same oven but separate tray. Very tasty!
— Somewhat
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
We have 2 in our family with Celiac who are quite sensitive to contamination. We had the MOST amazing gluten free pizza AND no contamination! I can't recommend the pizza enough! Those without Celiac in our family had regular crust pizza and agreed the gluten free crust was actually better! LOVED the Quarto Formaggio pizza! We made reservations as it did get busy at lunch.
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
The GF dough is unlike any other I've ever had! My non-Celiac husband even loved it!
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
The most amazing GF pizza we have ever eaten!!! No cardboard crust here.
— Somewhat
— Some
— Excellent
Amazing gluten free pizza. As good as what you get in Italy
— Very
— Most/All
— Excellent
Best house made GF pizza crust! This place is a must! They make their own GF crust that the chef has perfected! Love this place! AMAZING SERVICE AS WELL!!
— Very
— Most/All
— Excellent
Best gluten free pizza I've ever had! It was so fluffy I almost didn't believe it!
— Very
— Some
— Excellent
I ordered a pizza from here and it was delicious. I felt completely fine after eating it. I would say it is safe for celiacs!!
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
The best gluten free pizza I’ve ever in my life. Even my family loved it to the point where we had to ask twice if our pizza really was gluten free because the dough was so fluffy.
— Somewhat
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
If I could relive eating this meal again, I would. Truly the BEST gluten free pizza I’ve ever had. No reaction (I am celiac and sensitive to cross contamination), and my boyfriend loved his gluten pizza as well. Great staff, great vibes, and great food and drinks. If you are in the area, come here!!!!
— Somewhat
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
This place was amazing! I don't usually leave reviews but this time I had to - their gf pizza crust is homemade and incredible. They also have a flourless chocolate cake that heavenly! The staff is so friendly and kind. Wish I could eat there everyday!!
— Very
— Some
— Excellent
Service was amazing, very knowledgeable on GF, food was Amazing
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
The very best gluten free pizza I’ve ever had (and it’s my favorite food group). The closest thing to gluten Ive had in years. My gluten eating friends were highly impressed and could barely tell the difference. If going at a busy time be sure to make a reservation.
— Somewhat
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
The pizza was phenomenal! Bubbly crust, authentic sauce. I am not sure about cc issues. I am very sensitive to it, but I did not get sick.
— Somewhat
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
Best GF crust we’ve had. It even had crust bubbles! No issues with a Celiac diner. Great non-GF also.
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
Sat down to eat here, but ended up leaving after speaking with the waiter about gf precautions. The gf pizzas are “prepared” separately, but the toppings are added on the same counter as the regular pizzas. Not celiac safe in my book
— Not at all
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Ate here a couple years ago and the pizza was delicious and I was satisfied with their safety measures at the time. I went back recently and was told that the the GF pizzas now go in the same oven as the rest without a barrier. It’s really a shame because I recall the pizza being amazing, but it’s clearly not celiac safe at this time.
— Not at all
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent
As someone with Celiac, it was soooo good! Some of the best crust I have ever had
— Very
— Most/All
— Excellent
Without exaggeration- this was the best GF pizza crust and focaccia that we have ever had.
— Very
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
Pizza was delicious and the crust was chewy and amazing.
— Somewhat
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Most/All
— Excellent
I highly recommend if you are looking for pizza. The crust is thick and delicious.
— Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
— Some
— Excellent