The Secret Stash

17 recent ratings
$$ • Pizza Restaurant
Reported NOT to have a gluten-free menu, but gluten-free options are available
Popular gluten-free menu items: Pizza, Salad
Safety Rating
15 ratings

As rated by the community

303 Elk Avenue
Crested Butte, CO 81224

Most Recent Reviews


Symptomatic Celiac
2 days ago

The kitchen is full of flour so I wasn’t comfortable getting a gf pizza but if CC doesn’t affect you you’d be fine! I had the burrata salad which was fine

Safety
Taste
Variety
Celiac
2 weeks ago

I love the vibe of this place, and pre-celiac diagnosis, Secret Stash was my favorite pizza! So with all my fond memories of the food being delicious, I decided to risk some cross-contamination. The pizza (and GF crust) and burrata salad was delicious! But, my stomach was definitely upset afterwards. If I had stronger symptoms/reactions, I would not risk eating here. It was sort of stressful! The menu warning says something like, “heck, there’s gluten in the air here!” and that is almost certainly an accurate disclosure. Not sure if I’ll risk it again.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Celiac
5 months ago

Great restaurant and vibe. We got the Burrata salad and gluten free pizza. It was so good. Highly recommended.

Safety
Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Salad, Pizza
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Safety
  • — No dedicated fryer

Important

This establishment is NOT a dedicated gluten-free facility and may not be safe for those with celiac disease. Please contact the establishment directly to inquire about safety precautions.
Information contained in this listing is based on reports by the community. Please verify all information directly with the establishment.

Reported safety features

Other

Collections
In 1 Public Collection

Photos


Gluten-Free at The Secret Stash
Gluten-Free Pizza at The Secret Stash
Add a photo View all photos

More Reviews


Gluten Intolerant
6 months ago

100%, the BEST gluten-free pizza EVER!

Taste
Gluten Sensitive
6 months ago

Outstanding GF pizza. Be sure to eat in the request seating in the basement. It really cool and funky.

Safety
Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Salad, Pizza
Symptomatic Celiac
6 months ago

Great place to grab a pizza- will make anything GF. Didn’t feel sick and it’s always sooo good

Safety
Taste
Variety
6 months ago

The pizza was good but it did unfortunately make me very sick. My sister is gluten free as well and didn’t have any trouble so I guess it depends on your sensitivity.

Safety
Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Pizza
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — No gluten-free information on the menu
Safety
  • — No dedicated fryer
7 months ago

Waitress very knowledgeable. She thoroughly explained the kitchen used clean pans, new tools and a separate area to mix. Common oven. We loved the pizza. Crust was pretty standard for GF. Toppings amazing 😍. Great salad too. Had multiple town locals with celiac family members recommend restaurant. Told us to be very specific when ordering. Everything went well.

Safety
Taste
Variety
GF Menu Items
  • — Salad, Pizza
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — No gluten-free information on the menu
Safety
  • — Dedicated kitchen space
  • — Staff accommodates
  • — Knowledgeable staff
  • — Other dedicated equipment
  • — No dedicated fryer
Other
  • — Vegetarian options
  • — Vegan options
  • — Lunch
  • — Healthy options
Symptomatic Celiac
7 months ago

Secret Stash clearly states at the bottom of their menu that their gluten free crust is really just “gluten reduced” as there is so much flour in the kitchen and prep area that there is no way for it to be safe for those who are sensitive. I personally brought a thermos of pasta and some toasted bread from home and they didn’t mind.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Gluten Intolerant
11 months ago

The pizza was really tasty but they can’t promise no cross contamination. I ended up getting sick from here sadly so would not recommend

Safety
Taste
Variety
Gluten-Free at The Secret Stash
Gluten Intolerant
11 months ago

Good pizza! They have gf crust but I don’t know about safety of where they prep or bake it. They don’t mark which flavors are gf though.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Symptomatic Celiac
1 year ago

Great gluten-free pizza. Had Lisa’s Rouphage without the pasta and croutons, was a great alternative to pizza!

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — No gluten-free information on the menu
Symptomatic Celiac
1 year ago

Knowledgeable staff, no GF menu. There’s no guarantee they can keep things separate in the back so eat at your own risk. I appeared to be fine after my experience getting a GF crusted pizza.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — No gluten-free information on the menu
Safety
  • — Knowledgeable staff
  • — No dedicated fryer
Other
  • — Good for dairy-free
  • — Dog friendly
  • — Outdoor seating
  • — Dinner
1 year ago

I have definitely been glutened from my pizza two nights ago.

Safety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — No gluten-free information on the menu
1 year ago

This is the first pizza place I have gone to since being diagnosed with celiac almost 2 years ago. We are on vacation from Wisconsin and I am heavily relying on this app to find places to eat and I was so happy to find this place. The gluten free pizza was fantastic! The staff was amazing, and they made sure to check to make sure certain sauces we gluten free. I’ve had no issues after eating the pizza, and if we ever come back to Crested Butte I will definitely be eating here again.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — No gluten-free information on the menu
Symptomatic Celiac
1 year ago

The best place for celiacs in town! I’ve been coming here for many years and I’ve never had an issue here. Lots of fun pizzas to try, I highly recommend the FIG!

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Safety
  • — Dedicated kitchen space
  • — Knowledgeable staff
  • — Other dedicated equipment
Other
  • — Vegetarian options
  • — Vegan options
  • — Outdoor seating
Celiac
1 year ago

I’ve eaten here in the past with no problems. This time, however, I got extremely sick from the pizza

Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Symptomatic Celiac
2 years ago

They did great with the GF pizza. It’s very good and I didn’t have an issue (celiac).

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — No gluten-free information on the menu
Celiac
2 years ago

Took celiac very seriously. Had the Burrata salad and fig pizza. All great and did not get sick (very sensitive celiac).

Safety
Taste
Variety
Gluten Intolerant
2 years ago

Best gluten free and vegan cheese pizza I’ve ever had! Very nice staff and the food was great. Does have on the menu that they can’t guarantee there isn’t cross contamination but it is gluten reduced. Primarily due to flower etc in the air.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Safety
  • — Staff accommodates
  • — Knowledgeable staff
  • — No dedicated fryer
2 years ago

Server was very knowledgeable about cross contamination. All of the pizzas are cooked in the same oven but they are cooked on separate pans! I didn’t get sick after eating & had a very enjoyable time with my family!!

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Safety
  • — Knowledgeable staff
Gluten-Free Pizza at The Secret Stash
2 years ago

Delicious food and I didn’t get sick. Unsure what steps kitchen staff take yo reduce cross contamination, but I didn’t get sick.

Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Celiac
2 years ago

We had a large group and they were able to seat us in their lower area. They have a really nice gf crust made on house. Great server and no after affects after eating here.

Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Celiac
3 years ago

Holy Crusty Butts this place is AMAZING! I got the notorious fig with their DF cheese and it was HEAVEN! The cheese wasn’t rubbery and gross like most dairy free cheese is. The wait staff was very knowledgeable and made sure I was safe! I have a severe reaction to gluten and I didn’t get sick one bit! (Celiac and lactose intolerant). Highly recommend this place.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Symptomatic Celiac
3 years ago

Great service with Dianna!!! Gluten-free pizza was the best crust I’ve had. Crispy too! I want to know what brand you use.

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — No gluten-free information on the menu
3 years ago
Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Separate gluten-free menu
Other
  • — Good for dairy-free
  • — Vegan options
  • — Lunch
  • — Healthy options
Celiac
4 years ago

Ordered the GF crust Fig pizza. This was quite possibly the worst GF pizza crust I have had in the 3.5 months since I was diagnosed. Granted, I am a pizza snob from Chicago. But this was ... not good. The interior is chewy in a bad way. The edges are rock hard.

Sadly I had such high hopes based on previous reviews. Figured it would be hard to find good GF food in ski towns. I wasn’t wrong.

(If you’re looking for a better option while your friends/family eat what is likely delicious non-GF pizza, Ryce Asian Bistro was amazing. Huge portions, very accommodating, and I did not get sick!)

Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Symptomatic Celiac
4 years ago

Overall good gf pizza. The waitress seemed knowledgeable and I didn’t get sick!

Safety
Taste
Variety
Is there a gluten-free menu?
  • — Gluten-free items are marked on the main menu
Other
  • — Lunch
  • — Outdoor seating
  • — Delivery
Celiac
5 years ago

After reading some of the reviews, I was a little concerned about trying Secret Stash pizza with my son. So I called and got some good info about how they bake their pizzas (see below). The pizza here is Delicious and the staff was very knowledgeable about Celiac. If they didn’t have an answer to my questions, they asked someone who knew. They have GF crust that they do not prepare in house so risk of cross contamination is less. They use clean gloves to make the pizza. They bake each pizza on its own pan. Pizzas are all cooked in the same oven, however. Their menu says Gluten reduced ( not gluten free) bc of course there is flour in the air. My son is Celiac and sensitive to any gluten and he did not get sick. He Loved his GF pizza. We also ate salad from the salad bar (sounds crazy at first) but I talked to our server about it and then we checked out the salad bar. The croutons were separate from everything else. The dressings are Gf. The ranch is in a pump so risk of x contamination is less. My son had a salad and was fine. We would highly recommend this restaurant for both Celiac and non Celiac people bc the food is So good!

Safety
7 years ago

I called and they make the GF pizzas in the same oven as the others. Also there’s a salad bar so plenty of room for contamination.

Safety
7 years ago

The gluten free pizza is very good and they have great salads too! Love the ambiance!

Celiac
8 years ago

Menu lists it as "Gluten reduced" NOT for celiac's.

Safety
Celiac
8 years ago

Notorious FIG hands down the best GF pizza I have ever had! My kids wolfed down their gf cheese and pepperoni and asked if we could go back again later in the week!

11 years ago

Amazing gluten free pizza!!

11 years ago

Excellent Pizza. I usually order the Notorious Fig (prosciutto, Mozzarella, Blue Cheese, Figs, and finished with Truffle Oil).

More Info