I've been to Café Chocolade and I do enjoy many of their GF baked items. They are all very flavorful.
That being said, I have to believe that all of these 5-star reviews are bogus. The reviews have the same themes in them ("Great parking," "I live in Moon and used to go to the East Side," etc) but what made it certain for me is this: I simply cannot believe that so many people in Pittsburgh choose the incorrect "there" when speaking of THEIR products! This makes me sad too, because I believe the food is good and of quality and the owner seems nice. But the parking is nothing fancy (about 5 spots only) and the place is tiny and off the beaten path.