I think that the negative reviews may have been written before Carlucci's had a dedicated gluten free menu. They have an extensive gluten free selection, including pasta and pizza!!! When I asked for sautéed broccoli rabe, the waiter notified me that I should get it steamed because the sautéing wouldn't be gluten free. A pleasure!! I have been aware of my celiac disease for 7 months now and every restaurant that is as careful as Carlucci's makes it so much better!
Yes