Review of Mama's Italian Restaurant

1352 Montauk Hwy, Oakdale, NY 11769

Overall Rating

Review


The Pro's: the GF menu was extensive, the fried calamari was good. They offer gluten free bread.

The Con's: The waitstaff was awful, you want gluten free bread? Wait a half hour and you'll get 1 slice. The chairs were hard, the lighting was harsh, the prices don't match the decor. The baked clams were fishy and gross (how can you mess up baked clams?) and the Chicken Marsala pizza was an under-cooked sloppy mess. I would rather pop a frozen gluten free pizza in the oven, than waste my time and money eating here.

Updated 10 years ago