Staff was knowledgeable, but Pizza fell short. We ordered the Gluten-free House Special. Topping were great. Not enough meat for my liking. Pizza Crust not cooked enough or toppings too wet for pizza. They carry the SweetStreet GF Brownie which is an outstanding product. Didn't order it cuz my stomach was full of GF raw pizza crust.
I used to go to Mellow Mushroom too much when I lived in Savannah and I could eat gluten. I know what their real pizza tastes like. But I haven't been in years because of my diagnosis. I'm sad. This was not a good gf pizza. The crust is tasteless! Mine was also slightly burned around the edges. Plus, they are honest and tell you what toppings you can have to minimize cross contamination. I had the GF Veg Out. It's just a bunch of raw vegetables thrown on the tasteless gf crust. Raw onions, raw green peppers, canned olives, singed and limp spinach. With all the sauce, it was just soggy with raw veg. Just a bad salad on bad dough.
My waitress didn't inspire confidence and came back to confirm my order, with a questioning voice, twice. But when it came out and I saw my pizza compared to my husband's pizza, I knew it was gf. It looked so sad compared to his beautiful and delicious looking normal pizza.
Sorry, I won't go back.
GF pizza with DF cheese, meats, and veggies. Tasted amazing. Server was knowledgeable and accommodating. Double checked ingredients for me
Wherever we travel I am always happy to find a Mellow Mushroom & this one in St Augustine did not disappoint! I always feel safe eating at MM. The wait staff is knowledgeable. I have a severe dairy intolerance as well as celiac. This MM is awesome, bonus we were allowed to bring our dog, seating on the patio!
(Review from a local) We eat here and get delivery regularly. They’ve never gotten us sick. Best celiac experience we’ve had at a restaurant ever! They are as good as some Disney restaurants when it comes to allergies!! They have a separate prep space and allergy oven. They use corn masa to roll their regular pizzas instead of flour so airborne gluten isnt too much of an issue. We were able to speak directly with the manager and he made the pizzas himself to ensure no cross contamination and myself and my celiac son felt great after. Also, they carry glutenberg beers for those that like to enjoy a certified gluten free beer with their pizza.
We had a wonderful time my husband and daughters are gluten-free and my husband is also alpha gal positive. We shared with the server or assorted food allergies and she was awesome with recommendations. We loved the gluten-free pizza and the appetizer wings were to die for.
My daughters and I had the gluten free pizza and it was excellent. They also offer dairy free cheese.
Staff was very knowledgeable about celiac and the gf offerings. The server explained that not all of the typically gf items (like pineapples) are on their separate gf line but the ones indicated in the menu are (pineapples don’t belong on pizza anyway). My daughter was very pleased with both the flavor and the portion size of her small pizza. Thanks! We will return!
Very safe for celiac. Their gluten free pizza was not the best. I would recommend ordering something else.
Amazing GF pizza, they're sauce is unbelievable. Very good price at 11.99 a pizza plus cost of toppings but ya don't even need 'em. Pizza is that good.
We had a great time, great food, awesome service, and recommend sitting outside
I was here last week and had a pizza out for the first time in over two years and it was FANTASTIC. They use smart flour crust and I had green pepper and bacon on mine. Not only that but it was a good sized pizza (12") and I was able to take some home.
This is the best gluten free pizza that I have ever had. Everything is prepared separately and is free of cross contamination. I am very sensitive and had no problems at all. The staff is very well trained and my waiter was wonderful. The waiter reported to us that many people with out allergies come in for the gluten free pizza because it is their favorite. I highly recommend Mellow Mushroom.
Excellent GF White Pizza and also GF Chesse Pizza! Great Manager Amber and Bartender Tim! We'll be back!!
Service was great. Pizza was good but not great. I was hoping for better crust on it. The crust was really thin and soggy in the middle (although I like and am used to the thin gluten free crust). It was one of the better gluten free pizzas I've had, that's for sure, just was hoping for a bit better crust from a place that was rated 5 stars.
smart flour pizza crust...the kids approved! and I enjoyed the specialty pizza with the GF crust! would go back :-)
GF pizza was great. Kitchen staff has been trained on how to handle food for celiacs. Server was also well informed.
Awesome service. My wife is G-F and we're both dairy free. This pizza place has Daiya Cheese and GF crust. It is great. It is served by someone with gloves and the pizza is cooked on a special tray to keep it clear of other crusts.
The gf pizzas are tasty and there are several options. They have Angry Orchard Ale on tap.
4 stars pending 5, once we come back (pretty sure it is inevitable, the mushroom pizza had my husband licking his fingers, sadly the toppings aren't guaranteed GF ) I had the GF Kosmic Karma. The crust had good chew and flavor, and the toppings were tasty despite my congestion and inability to properly smell. I definitely recommend this place.
Pizza was a definite 5stars. I'm not GF, but my husband, who is, and I shared a pizza. We both thought it was great! I did, however, have to take away a star for the difficulty in getting there and poor parking options. It took us so long to travel from I-95 (8mi: 105 min round trip) we called in the pizza to go and just ate it in the car. Good thing, too , bc they were packed with a long waiting line and we couldn't 'to find a place to park even just to grab our to-go order!
We eat here regularly and do not get sick. Not all items are able to be certified gluten free. We also get vegan cheese and they have been good about checking the order before giving it to us. Twice now, they have made it incorrectly and caught the error first and remade it for us. I feel very comfortable eating the gluten free pizza here.
We ordered two GF pizzas (House Special and Kosmic Karma). I’m not a picky eater and enjoyed them, but the crust is kinda like cardboard. I wouldn’t not order from them again, but I think there are better options in the area.
Website indicates they are Certified GF and have cross-contamination awareness and procedures.