Mitchell's Fish Market

average food with below average service. They have a gluten free menu but no idea about cross contamination

Mitchell's has a dedicated GF menu and my wife loves several of the dishes. They offer GF soy sauce for the shanghai trio which is salmon, scallops and shrimp over rice and spinach. excellent seafood all around!

Stated they had multiple gluten free options. Ordered crab legs, vegetables, and mashed potatoes. Tested all with Nima gluten sensor and veggies and potatoes came back with gluten. Some upset stomach shortly after eating. Staff stated it was supposed to be gf.

The staff was friendly, patient, and knowledgeable about precautions to take for celiac disease. The waitress explained protocol was to inform manager who would oversee all. The manager introduced himself and was friendly, respectfully, knowledgeable and explained how staff worked to manage allergies and gluten. I felt safe and comfortable. My food was absolutely delicious!

I avoid gluten (and dairy, but not as sensitive to that), and got glutened here today. Had the Shanghai Shrimp Salmon and Scallops. The waitress assured me that she poured the Tamari (to avoid soy sauce), into the little bowl that was on my plate with the fish and rice. It must have been something that happened in the kitchen. I called back and told the manager, and she apologized and was going to followup with the kitchen. If you are celiac, beware.

Gf...Wonderful food and service!

Fantastic gluten free menu options. The seafood Cobb is my favorite.

Horrible food and servicd.

Didn't get glutened. House salad with poppyseed dressing. Blackened mahi mahi with smashed potato and broccoli and carrots. Creme brûlée for dessert. It's expensive and the food is marginal but I appreciate not getting ill.

I ordered Salmon off of the gluten free menu. I verified with my server as I was served that it was gluten free. I was assured it was. I was sick 20 minutes after eating.

I had a positive experience at Columbus Fish Market. They have a gluten free menu that was not particularly extensive but still had several good seafood options. The manager came to my table to discuss gluten free food prep. I did not get sick afterward.

good food, very fresh. sat at the bar and they were very helpful with recommendations. Familiar with Celiac. GF menu.

We've always loved this restaurant, but now coming here with a Celiac daughter we have a whole new appreciation. The staff was very knowledgeable and even though the gluten free menu was great, they helped us create an all-original dish for our daughter (and she didn't get sick). We definitely recommend it!

Loved this restaurant! Make a reservation. Very nice atmosphere. Great service. No gluten issues. Delicious food!!!

Decent food. They were very nice about accommodating my dietary restrictions (gluten, dairy, soy), and I did not get sick after eating there.

They changed owners earlier this year and it's no longer a Cameron Mitchell's restaurant. They still have a gf menu with a handful of items but do not offer gf bread. Our server was not knowledgable of food allergies and kept suggesting options with gluten, I had to remind him over and over that I had a gluten allergy- very frustrating and it made me a bit nervous. Overall, the experience was definitely not as great as other Cameron Mitchell restaurants in regards to their allergy accommodations.

Always good. Staff understand the issues of serious gluten intolerance

Aside from the fact my food was awful and the service was worse, the waitress didn't know anything about the gluten free menu. She brought my appetizer out with soy sauce, even after I specified I was gluten free. The GF menu also stated that all of the Fresh Catches can be made gluten free. I ordered the lobster and shrimp stuffed cod and when it arrived as just cod I was confused. I asked the waitress and she told me that I actually ordered the only fresh catch that can't be prepared the same way. Which would have been useful information before I ordered originally.

They are very knowledgable and GF has a menu where everything is clearly labeled.

Great stuff!! Recommend to any Celiac.

I ate two bites and had an immediate reaction. The manager and chef swore it was gluten free but it looked like a bit of soy sauce had gotten on my white rice (the bite I ate was completely white, but didn't taste like plain rice so I started to dig around in it.) The seafood I did taste was a bit over cooked. I would not recommend this place if you are very sensitive.

Enjoyed the blackened trout and grilled vegetables. Service was OUTSTANDING. Didn't care for the cerveche appetizer. Tons of corn with spots of seafood the size of a baby's pinky fingernail. Avoid it. Otherwise good. No problems with cross contamination

OMG amazing!!! Wide variety including dessert!!! I'm not a huge seafood lover but this place is ah-mazing!!!!

The service was terrible. It seems that they can do gluten free, but if you have any additional exclusion forget it. My daughter requested dairy free too...her whole meal had to be redone because apparently the waiter didn't understand butter is dairy. Extremely expensive for the quality and service. I would not recommend. There are a lot of other better choices in the area.

The waiter was knowledgeable and just made for a very fun dining experience, combined with good food and no issues or questions if my food was safe, I give them five stars!

knowledgeable soy allergy, gluten free menu. tasty grilled scallops and shrimp with baby reds and grilled veggies

Great gluten free menu. Can substitute for the soy sauce with a great sauce. Knowledgeable and friendly staff. Highly recommend.

Knowledgeable staff. I did not get sick and the salmon was delicious!

My husband and I went for lunch and they were very accommodating. I had their seafood Cobb salad. It was delicious, but I wish the portion size was better for the price.

This is my go to for a safe dining experience. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about celiacs and other allergies.

After explaining my condition to the waiter, I asked him to alert the chef AND double check my order before bringing it out. I ordered the g-free Shanghi style tilapia. When they brought it out I thought the soy sauce smelled WAY too good to be true so I insisted that the waiter double check gluten-free status with the chef. And the verdict... It was not gluten free. Brought me a "regular" order with wheat soy sauce. Should have known better when the waiter said he'd never heard of "that disease" before. Haven't eaten at a restaurant in 6 months but wanted so badly tonight to celebrate my fiancé's birthday along with the rest of the family. Sick & tired of going out to dinner and having a glass of water. Gluten free menus and restaurants that have them tend to support the fad, not the celiac. (Otherwise the staff would be properly trained). False hope just sucks.

Everytime I dine at Mitchell's, I am extremely pleased with the result. The menu selection, flexibility, service and knowledgeable staff are wonderful. I have yet to have a mediocre meal. I can always guarantee a great experience and highly recommend this restaurant! !

No GF menu but the staff was helpful. I got a raw tuna dish that was excellent.

Fantastic food here. Outdoor patio, friendly staff, wish they had more gf options tho. Superb seafood!

Awesome food options and service! This is my place for a splurge! Delicious and so fresh, staff bent over backwards to accommodate or suggest a GF supplement

I got the salmon. It was very good.

Great fresh good. Staff well-educated and very helpful.

Great food! Many gf options

Best salmon I've ever had! Served on a cedar plank with amazing fresh grilled vegetables. Service and atmosphere were great.

Excellent! Ask for Gluten Free Menu.

A little pricey, but well worth it. Fish is fresh and excellent, and they offer a nice selection of GF options. Staff has always been very well informed and super helpful about GF. Best fresh seafood in Indy, IMHO, and is a great place to eat for everyone, GF or not.

Wonderful place and awesome Gluten Free menue!!!

Took my husband here for his birthday. When I made reservation the hostess asked if it was a "special occasion?" Upon arriving he was greeted with a hand written birthday card! Our server, Jenn, was knowledgeable and so sweet. Price was good, food was delicious, and he was even treated to a free dessert!

Salmon was grilled on us Cedar plank. It was great and the staff were knowledgeable and very friendly I recommend it to anyone who is gluten free like me

Waiter very knowledgeable. Great gluten free menu.

We have eaten here several times and have never had a problem. The staff seems well-educated and the chef always willing to make accommodations . Food is very good. And, they let you bring your own bread!

Gluten free menu and the staff are careful. Celiac seems to be understood.

Excellent seafood and a gluten free menu

Great place knowledgeable staff, beautiful view! I would visit again and again

Food was ok. I had better salmon at the Hyatt regency in Dearborn. Also they DON'T HAVE GF BEER!!!!!:( Again if you are claiming to have GF menu you should have beer too.:(

Really nice selections and great service.

Awesome gf food, staff very knowledgeable about allergies, and excellent service. Dinner can be rather pricey, however same awesome food for lunch at almost half the price! A must try!